Except then there are those pesky CGNATs to handle including Chinese Great Wall.
Anyway, high profile spammers will emulate enough of the browser to render any measure based on browser anomaly detection worthless. Including using a headless browser. The only way to defeat them would be too put some quite computationally intensive JS operation... (On par with mining, ruining all the laptops, phones and tablets. But you can make it not trigger every time.) This would make spamming expensive.
Server-side we have excellent AI spam filters that nobody seems to be using to fire off a captcha check later. The big problem here is that you cannot offload to some provider without inviting big privacy concerns. (Same problem as forum/chat/discussion platform providers.)
Do you think a botnet with 10k machines is going to be meaningfully inhibited by making each machine's cpu run calculations for a second or two for each submission?
I'm sure reCAPTCHA looks at the IP and IP block as one of the inputs to its ML algorithm, but as one or two of perhaps a dozen different features - including mouse movement and/or keyboard input, which is quite a bit harder to fake.
Based on actual experience of fighting spammers, that isn't the case. Like a lot of people new to spam fighting you're making assumptions about the adversaries that aren't valid.
Some will be stopped by the simplest protection mechanisms.
Some will be indistinguishable from real humans, and you won’t be able to stop them without crippling your services for your real users.
But those are the two extremes. The real problem is the ones between those extremes.
Every intentional stumbling block you put in the path to try and stop those in the middle might also have a negative impact on your real users. The real problem is that the most troublesome attackers will learn and adapt to whatever stumbling blocks you put in the path. So, how many of your own toes are you willing to sacrifice with your foot guns in the name of stopping the attackers?
This isn't easy and many firms fail at it, but you it can be done and we routinely did it.
It is?
Thought bot detection was only done during registration etc. to stop them from sending spam etc. to real users.
If anything the javascript world we live in helps combat this. You need insane resources on the client just to have a page open. Several orders of magnitude more than the server need to generate and send that page.