News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:White House: What's Blocking Innovation in America? My A... by tptacek on Saturday February 12, 2011 @07:00PM (#2211553)
When the startup lawyer says that the protections for parties in startups from defection and unfair competition are derived from IP laws, I tend to believe him. You seem to retort, "but that's contract law!". But those are contracts protecting intellectual property.

Postgres, sqlite, BSD, and clang are BSD-licensed open source. But many more projects are GPL-licensed, and thus depend entirely on IP law, than those that aren't. Without IP law protections, those GPL projects compete on an unlevel playing field with companies that would otherwise be free to capitalize on all their work without contributing anything back.

Finally, of the list of YC companies here: http://yclist.com/, how many take no advantage of IP laws? How many are entirely BSD-licensed open source? How many have no trade secrets?

Re:White House: What's Blocking Innovation in America? My A... by ZeroGravitas on Sunday February 13, 2011 @04:35AM (#2212431)
IP-based startups (and their lawyers) defending IP laws is similar to big agriculture (and their lobbyists) defending farm subsidies. Yes, they will be affected by the change, but if they don't even bother to try and make an argument as to why society would be worse off under a different system then why would you listen to them?

Though personally once you've used the phrase "Intellectual Property" the game is already over. The various things people lump under that heading are so broad and disparate that you might as well just say "laws need changing" and counter with "we need laws". That's not even getting into the fact that you're implicitly accepting that you're talking about a form of property, rather than government regulation and monopoly grants.

Re:White House: What's Blocking Innovation in America? My A... by throw02082011 on Sunday February 13, 2011 @10:06AM (#2212878)
I assume you include every manufacturer of goods that has a patent as "IP-based startups"as well? Patents are IP. Just because you don't like Angry Birds or some other app maker getting rich doesn't mean IP is bad.

Could it use reform? Heck yeah. But your view is no better than the supposed lawyers you hate against.