Of the companies on this list, make an argument as to the percentage of them that would be viable in a world where copyright on source code wasn't enforceable, where there was no trade secret law and publication of company secrets was thus protected under the First Amendment, and where any element of content on any web page reachable on the Internet could be freely lifted and used by any other company.
Here is an absolutely excellent cross section of the
startup world
It's irrelevant. In an absence of IP, the playing field would be totally different, and hence there would be other strategies and other startups.That's why I brought up opportunity cost in my parent post.
The playing field would be completely different, but not necessarily inferior.
Both you and the original poster are trying to make a defence of IP based on circular logic that avoids considering opportunity cost. That's invalid.
'If the system changes, then it produces a different set of results'
I could use my godlike powers to create a true democracy, a dictatorship or a theocracy. Different people would raise to the top in each case.
Pointing to the people who have risen to the top for any one of those and saying 'if you changed the system, none of those people would be there' is simply a trivial truism, it is not an argument for not changing the system.
Conclusion: most YC companies are significantly dependent on IP laws to operate.
Its widely accepted that where an absence of evidence exists, it is logically and scientifically reasonable to come to a conclusion based on an individual's personal bias.
That said, I haven't heard of most of the companies on that list. The ones I have heard of, would all probably do fine (or, as well as under the current system).
where there was no trade secret law and publication of company secrets was thus protected under the First Amendment
The first amendment just means the government can't censor you.
I disagree with your claim, but even if it were true, isn't that tantamount to, say, legislation making the sale of automobiles illegal in order to preserve the viability of the horse-drawn wagon market?
If the government gave people privilege for howling at the moon, there would be a startup scene around it. That's not a defence of the policy.
That blanket statements is false. Even if it were true, there are mechanisms that predate conceptions of IP that can be used to defend trade secrets, particularly contract. Only some do. And then there are a raft of startups that can't and don't exist as a result of IP laws.