News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ontology for the life sciences: genes, proteins, diseases... by DrScientist on Tuesday January 21, 2020 @07:16AM (#22106239)
I'm skeptical about these - as often it's missing the point.

Two main challenges:

- one world view of categorization does not meet all needs and is fragile over time

- the challenge is still shared understanding between humans, not between computers.

Let me explain the second:

You have a large set of computer readable definitions - painstakingly built.

You have some new data that needs mapping into the ontology.

Typically a person has to do that.

To map they need to understand the ontology in the same way as every other person doing mappings.

The larger, more complex/'definitive' the ontology the harder this is.

Finally, science moves on and your ontology/and or understanding is out of date.

That's not to say shared definitions are not incredibly useful - just that writing them down in a computer friendly way doesn't guarantee that the definitions are actually shared between people.

There are no comments on this comment yet.