News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins by virtuous_signal on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:51PM (#22087098)
That's true, and in addition to the claim that legacy admits make the entire college experience more affordable for everyone else, is probably the strongest objection.

I would venture the following: if we agree on the norm that "power should stop being transferred dynastically or through nepotism in a modern civilized society", and abolishing legacy preferences bring us closer to this norm, then the negative effects will be transient, and worth it.

Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins by protomyth on Saturday January 18, 2020 @04:37PM (#22087442)
That's never going to happen unless you truly change human nature. We are tribal and protect our families. Nepotism is a family member making life better for other members of the family. I'm not sure we will still be a society if we eliminate family bonds.
Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins by throwawayjava on Saturday January 18, 2020 @05:48PM (#22087918)
> I'm not sure we will still be a society if we eliminate family bonds.

There's a significant difference between not having nepotism and eliminating family bonds.

> We are tribal and protect our families.

Many of virtuous_signal's arguments boiled down to the observation that protecting your family via nepotism or dynastic preference isn't even necessarily good for the effected family member in the long run. I think that poster makes a good argument that dynastic preference in university admissions is a net negative for its beneficiaries.

The negatives of nepotism also show up in business, where, with rare exception, nepotism tends to genereate a huge drain on both productivity and external respect.

Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins by jeegsy on Monday January 20, 2020 @12:47PM (#22100589)
I always hesitate with these sorts of effects calculations. Depending on how long or how transient these negative effects are, a lot of folks could get screwed through no fault of their own.