Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
by mobilefriendly on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:22PM
(#22086890)
"mediocre children of alumni" This is an unfair description of the advantage of legacy at an elite school. It's typically an edge, like playing a sport or belonging to an under-represented demographic.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
by virtuous_signal on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:26PM
(#22086915)
I'm aware that it's typically an edge; what I mean by "mediocre" is not a personal description, but rather the state of being quantitatively less meritorious than those students who gained admission without the legacy edge.
Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
by CydeWeys on Saturday January 18, 2020 @05:49PM
(#22087932)
The non-mediocre children of alumni can still get in. "Mediocre" is being used here in a relative sense.
Re:Ending Legacy Admissions at Johns Hopkins
by michaelt on Saturday January 18, 2020 @08:24PM
(#22088696)
If the impact of legacy is small - equivalent to gaining 0.01 points of GPA - then if they need legacy to be admitted, they're only 0.01 points above being rejected - one of the least qualified students at the school.
And if the impact is large - equivalent to 1 point of GPA - then there are legacy admissions a full GPA point worse than the least capable of their non-legacy peers, which is even worse.
I agree mediocre is inaccurate, because mediocre means half way to the top, and students who need legacy admissions are at the very bottom of the class.