Re:Whitney Tilson: Why We Covered Our Netflix Short
by nrao123 on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:54PM
(#2208874)
A substantial part of your $260 valuation
Comes from Terminal Value (I.e. Post 5 yrs)
And a 8% perpetual growth rate is an
extremely aggressive rate.
Basically, to justify the current value, The 5 year CAGR has to be way, way higher than 30%
Re:Whitney Tilson: Why We Covered Our Netflix Short
by 3am on Monday February 14, 2011 @11:49AM
(#2217426)
You're right of course - I really wanted to demonstrate that P/E ratios are a function of future growth and that a stock with a very high P/E can be underpriced.
I still know some people that think a company with a $4 share price is 'cheap' regardless of earnings, cash flow, or book value (and conversely, that high price stocks like AAPL or GOOG are 'expensive'). Not saying that is the case here, but there are plenty of people that make a similar mistake comparing P/E without considering growth rates.
Yes, I know low P/E strategies do well, and margins of safety, danger or trying to model growth rates more than a couple years out... but I'm not trying to turn HN into an investing forum :)
Thank you for calling me out on that!
That said I wouldn't buy NFLX either. But I wouldn't want to be short when 1/3 of the float is. If AMZN buys them out that would be the mother of all squeezes.