1) They have more data. It's not clear that it's better.
2) That difference is, to the eyes of many of us, showing up, making things worse, and then "pivoting".
3) I get to decide what I want to do. I want to add a project on X? I go work on it.
I'll Grant that The above doesn't really apply to pure math or philosophy
But right now, I'm working on projects in emerging infectious diseases, healthcare associated infections, some philosophy of science stuff, some algorithmic work in network science, and something that can best be described as "digital humanities".
Industry in healthcare, especially the tech industry, has a long road of trust building ahead of it.
I think we're also a little jaded. We've been talking about how big, real-time data streams like pharmacy sales data, social media, etc. are going to change the game for disease forecasting since I was an undergrad. We're still not even close.
Isn't that the point of being an academic? That you don't have much, if any, interest in generating a product?
For researchers at University of Toronto as well as within Google, neither (probably) wants to directly work on a product.
However both would certainly (At least in my experience) like their work to impact humanity on a wider scale then simply the number of citations their paper has. Again primarily thinking about applied researchers here.
So in that sense, both researchers are insulated from the producing of something business related based on their research. However one of them has a significantly greater chance of their research being used to actually affect people at large scale in their lifetime.
Further, companies can go from research to product that ostensibly makes a difference at scale with a speed that absolutely no University could.
I'm really not seeing any reason to stay in academia whatsoever if you want to do the most exciting applied research today. Maybe if you want to do basic science or something more obscure where the applications are very far off.