News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The economic effects of automation by philipkglass on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:39PM (#22077683)
When ATMs were introduced to banks in the 1980s, people thought bank tellers would quickly stop existing. Over time, each bank branch did end up employing fewer tellers. However, ATMs made it cheaper to operate bank branches, so more bank branches opened and there were eventually more bank teller jobs over all.

This comforting trend ended several years ago.

Here's a blog that plots teller employment numbers up through 2015:

https://greatdisruption2018.com/the-project/the-parable-of-t...

Here's the BLS data and outlook for the future:

https://www.bls.gov/ooh/office-and-administrative-support/te...

Teller employment peaked in 2007 at over 600,000. It's down to 472,000 as of 2018 and projected to decline another 12% by 2028.

You need to keep following the numbers to distinguish "the prediction of technological unemployment was premature" from "the idea of technological unemployment is mistaken."

Re:The economic effects of automation by VHRanger on Friday January 17, 2020 @03:32PM (#22078914)
Author here.

> Teller employment peaked in 2007 at over 600,000. It's down to 472,000 as of 2018 and projected to decline another 12% by 2028.

By that point we're not talking about the effect of ATMs anymore, which were introduced in the late 1980s/early 1990s.

This effect is more likely due to online banking and banking apps. We don't know yet how this change reallocated

> "the prediction of technological unemployment was premature" from "the idea of technological unemployment is mistaken."

Not really.

If you look at the other example (spreadsheet apps and bookkeepers) you see that even if a job stops existing, the remaining tasks get allocated elsewhere over time.

This overall dynamic is supported by the researchers in labor economics (see papers linked in the post)

This doesn't mean the transition is smooth, or even benefitial, for the job holder, but it doesn't translate to long run unemployability.

Re:The economic effects of automation by philipkglass on Friday January 17, 2020 @04:57PM (#22079881)
Economists often assume unlimited human wants and limited resources, giving rise to scarcity. Under the assumption of unlimited wants it is perfectly reasonable to predict that 40 years from now paid employment will remain as common as it was 40 years ago even if we don't know what the jobs will actually be.

I have a somewhat different perspective. I believe that human wants expressed in market economy terms -- e.g. "market demand" -- are satiable and becoming increasingly satiated among households with buying power (top two income quintiles in the US, for example [1]). There's limited demand for more consumption of services that already existed in the 20th century. You can only go to the doctor, the dentist, or the barber so often before more-frequent visits become a chore instead of a luxury.

New inventions may spur different demands but scope for aggregate growth is limited by hours in a day. Scrolling through Instagram replaces going to the movies and maybe some day exploring virtual reality replaces scrolling through Instagram. That reallocates entertainment demands but it doesn't necessarily mean more aggregate consumption or entertainment-employment.

There is big growth coming in home health aides, elder care, and similar jobs. But that's due to an aging population rather than the development of new service jobs for the 21st century.

Big growth in demand for "gig economy" services? Maybe. We'll see after the VCs stop tolerating losses.

[1] The unmet wants of the lower income quintiles are less significant in a market economy because they don't have growing buying power. Two former bank tellers aren't going to find employment walking each others' dogs.

Re:The economic effects of automation by freewilly1040 on Friday January 17, 2020 @03:37PM (#22078970)
Even if the decline in teller employment is not due to ATM's, the parable still suffers if another convenience innovation came along and did kill jobs.
Re:The economic effects of automation by roenxi on Friday January 17, 2020 @05:08PM (#22079995)
We don't know if innovation killed jobs here, we only have a graph showing there are less tellers.

It is expected that specific job titles will be obsoleted by technology. That is not a major issue when talking about the net effects on jobs. Society is littered with job titles (like Smith, Turner, Cartwright, Ackerman, etc, etc) that used to be everywhere and are now specialist roles or extinct.

Re:The economic effects of automation by VHRanger on Friday January 17, 2020 @03:42PM (#22079038)
The problem isn't that automation kills jobs. Those jobs reallocate over time.

We've seen automation act on the economy since the 1820s and nothing about deep learning or big data changes these dynamics.

The problem is that those who do lose their jobs have their lives altered for the worse, and those who get the better parts of automation don't share the benefits with the ones losing from it.

Re:The economic effects of automation by VHRanger on Friday January 17, 2020 @06:32PM (#22080803)
It didn't kill jobs in aggregate -- unemployment is at its lowest in decades.

The bank teller jobs might be disappearing over time, but they'll get reallocated.

The point of the article is that that reallocation process can be painful for those affected and increases inequality.

Re:The economic effects of automation by chii on Friday January 17, 2020 @07:04PM (#22081052)
is unemployment really as low as the reported figures?

i dont know what to think after looking at http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/unemployment-chart...

Re:The economic effects of automation by VHRanger on Sunday January 19, 2020 @11:24AM (#22092200)
Shadowstats is garbage.

Their inflation index is literally the official CPI index plus a constant (~2.8 last time I looked). He's that lazy about his scam.

The maintainer of shadowstats isnt in the business of maintaining an honest set of metrics, he's in the business of selling misinformation around hard to measure things.

Re:The economic effects of automation by snarf21 on Friday January 17, 2020 @02:26PM (#22078207)
This is exactly what happened but I assumed that the real cause of more branches was different. When banks stopped having to keep banking and investments separate, they wanted all the customers they could get. When you are averaging 10+% in the stock market while only paying 1% to consumers, you want as many consumers as possible. Then the only reason people would switch would be if a specific branch was more convenient for them or had more free ATMs. This became a question of customer acquisition. Plus you can write off the building and have a solid real estate business (ala McDonalds) for free. This also is what has pushed the banking consolidation trends so much. Banks could no longer get new customers via switching so they starting buying all the local players to keep their balance sheets growing.
Re:The economic effects of automation by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday January 17, 2020 @02:35PM (#22078308)
Also worth noting that this is absolute number of tellers, not tellers per US resident. Automation is very clearly reducing the demand for tellers on a per-potential-customer basis. For example, if we had seen the ratio remain flat, starting in 1980, we'd have expected a 50% growth in the number of tellers. But in fact it was flat (at least on the original article's graph).

I can't find numbers on what fraction of the population was unbanked in the '80s, but I can only imagine it was higher than it is now. That also is not accounted for in the parable.

Re:The economic effects of automation by LeoTinnitus on Friday January 17, 2020 @05:07PM (#22079970)
As someone who has worked at a financial in a rural area, I can assure you these people are still going to need tellers. I mean can you imagine explaining daily why someone gets charged an NSF fee or telling them that their check is a fraudulent check (sent by a scammer)? Also these people hate technology more than communists. So trying to sell them online banking is like telling them to become atheist socialists ready to fight for the revolution.
Re:The economic effects of automation by asdfasgasdgasdg on Friday January 17, 2020 @06:29PM (#22080778)
Nobody but nobody is saying that tellers will go away completely. Even buggy drivers still exist. The question is how many there will be.
Re:The economic effects of automation by cjblomqvist on Saturday January 18, 2020 @03:59AM (#22083286)
I'm a swede, who lived in the US 2009-2011. Back then I was amazed (and my friends as well when I told them about it) about how behind the US were tech wise when it comes to banking. From what I understand, we're in the forefront in Sweden, and now with all the bank startups, it's just taking off for real.

In Sweden the number of offices almost halved between 2007 and 2019. It takes time for these kinds of shifts to really take off. As a tech guy, I believe tech guys are often to optimistic about how fast non-tech _humans_ adopt tech (not because of tech, but because the change in lifestyle, which takes a lot of time for people). It's all the standard curve of adoption (first hype, then dispair, and then it truly happens and diffuses into massmarket).

Re:The economic effects of automation by program_whiz on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:43PM (#22077736)
Another note on that -- this is with increasing population and as they say, more bank branches opening than ever, so the automation effect has been very strong.
Re:The economic effects of automation by VHRanger on Friday January 17, 2020 @03:33PM (#22078926)
Arguably, a lot of the recent advances in banking automation aren't ATMs, they're online banking and banking apps.
Re:The economic effects of automation by turtlecloud on Friday January 17, 2020 @06:02PM (#22080537)
Well since the population of the US also increased, the actual decline would be much more pronounced if population had remained constant.