News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by coldtea on Thursday January 16, 2020 @06:18PM (#22070139)
"A spacefaring species could easily settle the entire Milky Way given billions of years"

That's somewhat of a wild assumption. What's a "spacefaring species"? Are we one since we've built a few ships and went to the moon?

Have they solved problems that might be intractable, like being able to travel anywhere remotely far in anything else than a "generation ship"?

Have they found the power to deploy those ships, and the materials (and amounts required of them) to withstand the radiation of space, incoming meteors and space debris over decades of flying, while still being able to propel their spaceships out of their gravity?

And why would those settlements even be able to survive in space, going out on some remote systems, and not knowing what they'll find there, and what exactly their Earth-like planets will provide them?

>William Newman and Carl Sagan later wrote a major rebuttal to Hart’s work, in which they argued that the timescales to populate the entire galaxy could be quite long. In particular, they noted that the colonization fronts Hart described through the Milky Way might move much more slowly than the speed of the colonization ships if their population growth rates were so low that they only needed to spread to nearby stars very rarely. They also argued that being a long-lived civilization is inconsistent with being a rapidly-expanding one, so any species bent on settling the galaxy would not last long enough to succeed. In other words, they reasoned that the galaxy could be filled with both short-lived rapidly expanding civilizations that don’t get very far and long-lived slowly expanding civilizations that haven’t gotten very far—either way, it’s not surprising that we have not been visited.

That sounds much more logical!

Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by baja_blast on Friday January 17, 2020 @01:58PM (#22077900)
One thing I think often gets ignored is the fact advanced civilizations require complex supply chains that would be extremely hard to bring to another planet. If anything goes wrong everyone is wiped out. Also hopping from one planet to the next would require the next planet to develop over a long period before they could start the next generation ship.
Re:Galactic Settlement and the Fermi Paradox by Teever on Friday January 17, 2020 @10:28PM (#22082052)
There's no proof that an advanced civilization requires a complex supply chain. In fact one of epochs of technological progression that occurs after an industrial revolution could possibly be an industrial simplification where supply chains and manufacturing processes reach a sort of apex in complexity that leads to absolute simplification.

It may just be that such a developmental landmark is a prerequisite of a civilization reaching interplanetary scale and it may even be a great filter.