No, it would not. ”...the records shall also include a legible hard copy or legible digitally scanned or other electronic copy of a hard copy of the identification document examined and, if that document does not contain a recent and recognizable picture of the performer, a legible hard copy of a picture identification card.” 28 CFR 75.2(a)(1); and there's a lot more besides, see https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/28/75.2 and 28 CFR 75 generally, as well as 18 USC § 2257.
It's no surprise at all that the sites demand an extraordinary amount of PII about the performers before they are allowed to post a single image.
Shame the punishments for leaking PII are nowhere near as severe.
Asking for a lot of PII is one thing, actually checking that PII to be accurate is another thing. The latter can be exploited to regain a slight bit of privacy.
The owners of this site should be ordered to pay restitution for the damages it has caused to all the performers impacted by this leak. If there are no consequences for things like this, companies will continue to be poor custodians of sensitive data that we entrust to them. The most vulnerable people in society will, as usual, suffer the greatest harm.
(1) ascertain, by examination of an identification document containing such information, the performer’s name and date of birth, and require the performer to provide such other indicia of his or her identity as may be prescribed by regulations; (2) ascertain any name, other than the performer’s present and correct name, ever used by the performer including maiden name, alias, nickname, stage, or professional name; and (3) record in the records required by subsection (a) the information required by paragraphs (1) and (2) of this subsection and such other identifying information as may be prescribed by regulation.
The law is IMO the least of your concerns here (you are not stealing or causing harm to anyone, so very little incentive for someone to look into it), the fallout when your real ID leaks like what happened here would be a much bigger concern especially for LGBT performers in certain regions.
Regarding credit cards, using a prepaid one or a service such a Privacy.com is enough so no fakery needed there.
None of that works in the realm of reality.
Creating a fake ID = super illegal.
Credit cards: prepaid can be detected and blocked, same as the privacy.com ones - especially when the credit card is being used to validate something. Look at any major fraud prevention software, these things are trivial.
In the real world, if you want to make money, you need to show and prove ID with matching banking details. Any inconsistencies and you don't get paid. This isn't something you can outsmart. People smarter than you and I have been thinking very long and hard about these points, much more so than the two minutes you took to think up your post. The idea is like those videos of 'primitive underground dwellings with a swimming hole on top'. Cute, creative, but terribly impractical and useless in any real world situation.
Yes that is correct. I am thankful I have other means of income meaning I don't need to model for a cam site.
> Creating a fake ID = super illegal.
Agreed. But if I'm at the desperate stage where I have no choice but to sign up to a cam site, I would prefer taking that risk than having such PII leak many years in the future and affect my career prospects (the article mentions some of the data being up to 20 years old - most of these people now have no doubt left the scene but their new life can now be screwed up by this data leaking). Neither is a good solution, but IMO the risks of the latter outweigh those of the former.
Regarding prepaid cards, yes I know they can be detected and blocked, but is there any incentive to do so? It makes sense for a performer to want to protect their privacy, so I don't see why the site would block these cards?
https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/codes_displaySectio...
> 470b. Every person who displays or causes or permits to be displayed or has in his or her possession any driver’s license or identification card of the type enumerated in Section 470a with the intent that the driver’s license or identification card be used to facilitate the commission of any forgery, is punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than one year, or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170.
You have to have the intent to commit a forgery. This is defined elsewhere but means to use the id to commit fraud.
So you have a novelty id that says your name is Mickey Mouse and you are 100 years old. You show it to your friends. Or maybe you get one as a gag gift for a friend. Not illegal in California. Using a fake id to misrepresent your age for legal purposes such as buying alcohol, tobacco, firearms, voting, acting in porn? Very illegal.
Ideally there should be a way for the websites to fulfil their legal obligations regarding age verification without actually handling any ID data themselves. Maybe a government-provided oAuth style service where you are redirected there, authenticate with the government (no extra risk there, they already have the data) and then they return a signed blob to the website asserting that you are of legal age without actually disclosing any details.