This argument needs to stop being used. Developed knowingly, a race-condition-full Therac-25 machine is objectively bad and a side-effect-free cancer cure is objectively good. It's along the same lines of "guns don't kill people, people kill people". It is a gross simplification of morality and ethical theories but nonetheless touted by people on the internet way too often. If anything it highlights the need for an ethics class as a requirement for any engineering degree.
You've gone and proven my point with that "developed knowingly" disclaimer, because rather than merely a technology, you're describing a deceptive and harmful act committed by a human being.
> Whether the developer intended it doesn’t change it’s an immoral technology if ever used.
Knowingly or negligently using unsafe medical equipment to treat patients is morally wrong, yes. You're again describing an act performed by a person and not the technology itself.
I'm not equating the two entities - they certainly have drastic differences in aims, scope, chosen targets, etc. But rather evil is evil, and should be called out directly rather than excused for not being as severe as some other, especially more removed, evil.
If anything's a delusion of righteousness, it's pacifism and isolationism.
If China’s facial recognition system is currently “too far”, how is this tech not also already too far? I guess if a technology is only used to recognize and assassinate foreign nationals, and not surveil citizens (which it will eventually be used to do), most Americans are okay with it. Some commenters are critical of this research, but the level of concern in these comments is way less than on posts about similar Chinese systems.
The point isn’t that this tech could increase accuracy and kill somewhat fewer civilians compared to the current amount of civilians killed regularly by U.S. drone and air attacks around the world. The entire basis for this activity - shooting missiles into civilian areas thousands of miles from home in endless wars - is the issue. The fact that the military sees a use for this kind of technology is the core of the problem, and no matter how well it works, it will only increase the efficiency of assassinations performed by the U.S. military, not abolish them.