Re:Bing smacks Google in new usability test
by brudgers on Thursday February 10, 2011 @09:32PM
(#2204905)
Mr. Cutts provides an example of Kim Kardashian videos on MSN linking to Bing as an explanation for the difference in success ratings between Bing and Google.
However if that were a significant factor, the similarity between the ratings for Bing and Yahoo would be somewhat unexpected without a demonstration that similar searches are directed to Yahoo. It would also seem that there is probably a significant enough behavioral difference between the user bases of Bing and Yahoo Search for Matt's "abandoned search theory" to be consistent with the similarity in success rates between the sites.
A more plausible explanation (but "creepier" in Googlespeak) for Google's results is that Google's sometimes practice of not linking directly to sites but rather to an internal redirecting page [as described by jacques mattheij here: http://jacquesmattheij.com/Microsofts+Bing+versus+Google%2C+...] lowers Google's success rate. It would also explain why Google questions the value of the metric so vigorously and why their criticism is speculative and anecdotal rather than more scientifically argued.
However if that were a significant factor, the similarity between the ratings for Bing and Yahoo would be somewhat unexpected without a demonstration that similar searches are directed to Yahoo. It would also seem that there is probably a significant enough behavioral difference between the user bases of Bing and Yahoo Search for Matt's "abandoned search theory" to be consistent with the similarity in success rates between the sites.
A more plausible explanation (but "creepier" in Googlespeak) for Google's results is that Google's sometimes practice of not linking directly to sites but rather to an internal redirecting page [as described by jacques mattheij here: http://jacquesmattheij.com/Microsofts+Bing+versus+Google%2C+...] lowers Google's success rate. It would also explain why Google questions the value of the metric so vigorously and why their criticism is speculative and anecdotal rather than more scientifically argued.
http://jacquesmattheij.com/Microsofts+Bing+versus+Google%2C+...