News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by fleitz on Thursday February 10, 2011 @08:33PM (#2204757)
"When the people fear their government, there is tyranny; when the government fears the people, there is liberty."

- Thomas Jefferson

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Thursday February 10, 2011 @08:57PM (#2204825)
“There can be no such thing, in law or in morality, as actions forbidden to an individual, but permitted to a mob” - Ayn Rand
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by cagenut on Thursday February 10, 2011 @09:22PM (#2204881)
"the opposite of anything ayn rand says" -me
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:20PM (#2205023)
Which specific thing should be permitted to only mobs that is not permitted of individuals?

Or is that a vacuous snark?

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by njharman on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:39PM (#2205059)
Taxing, ownership of life fundamentals (land, air, water), rearing/teaching of young, use of electromagnetic spectrum, governing.

But, I'm a socialist. Would also use the terms family, tribe, society, etc. instead of the purposefully biased "mob".

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Thursday February 10, 2011 @11:08PM (#2205130)
To be honest, I'm a bit surprised at the number of people who had a difficult time identifying who I mean. I'm actually a little-l libertarian and no great lover of government, so I understand the knee-jerk inclination, but why would I be stretching for the definition of a mob when there is another thing that can be called a "mob" in the story with no stretch at all?
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by cookiecaper on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:30AM (#2205837)
Taxation on things is a normal thing that is allowed to all individual entities within their sphere of control. If you own some item, you can effectively set up any taxation system on the usage of that item that you want. The governmental entity is allowed taxation powers because the people under its authority utilize its public benefits, such as police work, court systems, legislative considerations, and so on.

Likewise control of commons exists on an individual level as well -- if you are near a certain amount of water, you are generally free to own and control it. To the extent that you don't secure and maintain your property, your ownership is a vain deed.

Rearing and teaching of young is a really easy one, commonly given to individuals. Do you think all children should be taken out of individual households and placed in government-run child-rearing centers? That's what this one sounds like, and that is horrifically scary and ridiculous.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by fleitz on Thursday February 10, 2011 @09:01PM (#2204835)
Definitely agree with you I'd hate to see Anonymous individuals restricted from actions that HBGary, its subsidiaries, its employees, and clients take.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by pyre on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:12AM (#2206035)
If a mob overthrows the government that means that there were a lot of people upset with the government and it can be taken as the 'will of the people.' If a single person overthrows a government it could be seen as a dictatorship. I think that the Rand-ian sound byte fails here.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by Xurinos on Friday February 11, 2011 @10:44AM (#2206664)
"Don't live your life according to quotes." -- Keith Malley
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by gwern on Friday February 11, 2011 @10:31AM (#2206606)
> "What is the government? nothing, unless supported by opinion."

--Napoleon Bonaparte

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by heed on Friday February 11, 2011 @02:40AM (#2205517)
What about 'being a mob'?
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by Charuru on Thursday February 10, 2011 @09:35PM (#2204917)
Define mob? It's ok for the government to imprison people. But when I do it it's called kidnapping.

Edit: Just to clarify, I agree if you mean mob as in an actual mob. However you're replying to a parent who's talking about government, so that led me to think you're implying government is some form of a mob.

A representative government with powers endowed to them by the people and working within the limits of a codified legal system is very different from a mob.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sgrove on Thursday February 10, 2011 @09:42PM (#2204931)
I took it that the OP was referring to Anonymous as a mob... which is essentially one of the big draws of huge mobs - their anonymity.

Although I'm intrigued by the whole drama unfolding, I don't know that we can say there's justice/liberty in what the mob does if when one person did the same thing we'd say otherwise.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:18PM (#2205020)
Yes. It makes me very uncomfortable when the fact that "Anonymous" is committing some fairly serious crimes is apparently just glossed over because hey, we didn't like the target, so thumbs up!

It also makes me uncomfortable that I'm a bit nervous posting this point. This is not progress. This is not good. This is mob rule. We should be fighting this, not applauding it.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by trotsky on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:48PM (#2205087)
I don't really disagree with you, but I'm not sure what you mean by glossed over. It sounds like you'd like the journalist here to be condemning the actors or tsk-tsk-ing about the whole episode. But the lack of that isn't Anon getting a free pass, it's just how most neutral reporting is done. When you read a feature on a violent gang, or organized crime, or a serial killer generally you'll see a lot of matter of fact type of reporting, with the editorializing left up to the reader. It's not different here just because it's a mob.

And surely they're not getting a pass on the actual legal repercussions. The FBI took dozens of doors over the earlier DDOS's - I'm sure that they are quite keen at rolling up this incident into what is likely a very well staffed task force.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Thursday February 10, 2011 @11:28PM (#2205165)
Glossed over by us on this site and the Internet at large, not the press. I have no problem with the reporting. It bothers me that 30 comments in I appear to be the only person who even has concerns.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by cookiecaper on Friday February 11, 2011 @05:33AM (#2205845)
See my replies here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2203359 . The gist is that people don't really endorse Anonymous's actions, but the actions are unsurprising and generally uninteresting. The interesting part is the psychology and behavior of HBG[F] and its executives, specifically Aaron Barr, so that's what everyone is talking about. The silence shouldn't be taken as an unspoken endorsement of script kiddies.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by pyre on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:18AM (#2206048)
- An issue that you're not addressing well is that it's hard for a single person to DDOS, but it's a lot easier if you can get a group of people to run LOIC (i.e. the group's power draws from numbers).

- A group of people that decide to do something is not necessarily a mob.

- Anonymous is just a description for a set of people. The set of people most likely to participate in these raids. The entirety of Anonymous doesn't participate in each and every raid. Just the raids that they have the time, and motivation to do. If you can describe Anonymous as a mob, then you can also extrapolate that to the entire population of the planet. The entire planet of a group of people where sometimes some people decide to form a group and do things based on common interests.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by loewenskind on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:47AM (#2206122)
From your moral high horse can you see what the correct action to take is? More useless voting between two parties who take near identical actions?

Anonymous did what their target did. It was no more legal or illegal. If you want to punish them fine, but make sure you punish both criminals equally.

As we see in Egypt, fighting within the laws (which are just a list of rules made up by people in control) doesn't always give you the option to win.

[deleted]
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sigzero on Thursday February 10, 2011 @11:29PM (#2205171)
Um no. What they did was illegal. When you stoop to that level you aren't any better than the people your are trying to give the lesson to.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sudonim on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:23AM (#2205288)
I'm not sure that being "better" is what they are going for.

In one corner you have wikileaks, and anonymous challenging the state and a security firm, showing their cards against their will. In the other corner you have the government and a corporation trying to eliminate sources of criticism and dissent.

Wikileaks and Anonymous have won this round it seems, but when you have a battle on this scale that touches the very foundations of our government -- the very organism that determines what is legal and illegal, it seems that the normal rules just don't apply.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sage_joch on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:06AM (#2205256)
You shouldn't confuse legality with morality. Pointing out that something is illegal is not a very compelling argument that it's wrong. Imagine how ridiculous it would sound to chastise the Egyptians for breaking their curfew.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sudonim on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:24AM (#2205292)
Said more succinctly than my comment.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by trotsky on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:54AM (#2205345)
So you're saying intimidation, harassment and restricting speech is morally OK as long as it's loosely tied to an issue that you personally agree with?
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by pyre on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:19AM (#2206055)
How are they restricting speech? Anonymous released the information that he was supposed to release to the FBI anyways...
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by steveklabnik on Friday February 11, 2011 @08:18AM (#2206195)
People have been whining about how the DDOS is restricting the speech of MasterCard, not realizing that it has nothing to do with speech, and everything to do with adding an economic incentive to do the right thing.

While it also may be 'restricting speech' (corporate personhood has come a long way...) that's a side effect, not the reasoning or purpose.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by Starmonkey on Friday February 11, 2011 @10:57AM (#2206729)
Tell that to the US Government.

"After Anonymous imposed some very minimal cyber disruptions on Paypal, Master Card and Amazon, the DOJ flamboyantly vowed to arrest the culprits, and several individuals were just arrested as part of those attacks. But weeks earlier, a far more damaging and serious cyber-attack was launched at WikiLeaks, knocking them offline. Those attacks were sophisticated and dangerous. Whoever did that was quite likely part of either a government agency or a large private entity acting at its behest. Yet the DOJ has never announced any investigation into those attacks or vowed to apprehend the culprits, and it's impossible to imagine that ever happening.

Why? Because crimes carried out that serve the Government's agenda and target its opponents are permitted and even encouraged; cyber-attacks are "crimes" only when undertaken by those whom the Government dislikes, but are perfectly permissible when the Government itself or those with a sympathetic agenda unleash them. Whoever launched those cyber attacks at WikiLeaks (whether government or private actors) had no more legal right to do so than Anonymous, but only the latter will be prosecuted."

http://www.salon.com/news/opinion/glenn_greenwald/2011/02/11...

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by amadiver on Thursday February 10, 2011 @09:34PM (#2204915)
I'm curious as to why you don't see Anon's actions as mob justice? Or if you do, why that's okay?
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by pyre on Friday February 11, 2011 @07:23AM (#2206065)
Throwing around the term 'mob justice' is as meaningless as calling someone a 'freedom fighter.' Your freedom fighter is someone else's traitor/rebel/terrorist. I'm sure that Mubarak things that the Egyptians in the streets are trying to apply 'mob justice.'
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by fleitz on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:10PM (#2204999)
From where should a justice system derive its just powers?

Why is mob justice any worse than a justice system that allows people to be held indefinitely with out charge?

Why is mob justice any worse than a system that allows secret evidence which cannot be questioned or examined by the accused?

Would altering or abolishing a system that allows people to be held indefinitely with out charge be a good thing?

Either the justice system approves of this, or the rules of the system prevent it from taking action, either way it's broken.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Thursday February 10, 2011 @11:15PM (#2205139)
"Why is mob justice any worse"

As long as we're going all Socratic, why does the question of which is "worse" even matter?

We know what mob rule looks like. It's a failure state of human governance. Supplementing an imperfect system that can be metaphorically likened to mob rule with actual mob rule is not progress. I am not advocating for peacefully standing by while being beaten; I'm saying this is a bad tactic.

If you are concerned about injustice in the world, you can't make a more just world by committing your own injustices. No two people agree on how bad an injustice is; even if you think such things can be objectively measured somehow it is obvious that people in the real world don't agree on those objective measurements. Group A hits for 1 point, Group B measures that as a 2 point injustice and strikes back with a 2 point injustice of their own, Group A sees that as a 3 point injustice and strikes back with 3, and so on forever, until someone breaks the cycle. No amount of retaliation will ever make the society of A and B just, even though in my hypothetical example both sides are acting with perfect restraint and proportionality. (As you might imagine, this is the most unrealistic assumption my model makes.) However you intend to get to a just society, that's not it.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sesqu on Friday February 11, 2011 @12:55PM (#2207378)
If you are concerned about injustice in the world, you can't make a more just world by committing your own injustices. No two people agree on how bad an injustice is

Your second statement is at war with your first. Clearly, people can compare injustices, or else there would be no such thing as "more just". They don't have to be able to assign scores to injustices, they just have to reason that an injustice they can't choose can be replaced by one they can choose. That's pretty much how justice works.

Your example was also shit. While it is common to escalate injustice as a game strategy, that's neither a hard rule nor how it's usually done. In my experience, pardons are far more common, and are in fact closer to theoretical optima. Eventually, someone breaks the cycle (pretty unjust, right?), and the injustices in the world dramatically reduce. And then there's all the undervaluations of injustice you ignored - the traditional justification for secrecy.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Friday February 11, 2011 @03:53PM (#2208084)
"Your second statement is at war with your first."

You missed the switch to differing valuations between two different people, it seems. You spoke as if either we're only talking about one person doing the comparison or you've casually assumed there is the objective metric I explicitly mentioned in play. No contradiction.

"Your example was also shit."

And you're just looking for reasons to tear something apart without doing the hard work of examining what was actually being said. Your nits are irrelevant to my point. I didn't give a treatise on the full value of how to create justice in the world, I'm speaking to the example at hand of how "Anonymous" retaliated and how people are applauding it when they shouldn't be. No wonder you consider it "shit", you're not even willing to grapple with what I said. You haven't fairly valuated it in the first place.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sesqu on Friday February 11, 2011 @04:37PM (#2208248)
You missed the switch to differing valuations between two different people, it seems.

No, I refuted the importance of it. My point was that while there might not be a universal, metric, objective measure of injustice agreed to by all involved, we don't actually need one to make social decisions (funny how three of the four qualifiers I used are essentially the same). Near Pareto efficiency exists for justice, and beyond that, numerous partial orderings have been developed over the millenia, based on perceived necessary conditions for the existence of societies.

Your nits are irrelevant to my point.

Then I must have misunderstood your point. It seemed to me that you claimed retaliation is always unjust and perfectly proportional retaliation is one-upmanship, and I don't agree at all. Since that's how I saw your argument, that's what I replied to.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by jerf on Friday February 11, 2011 @09:56PM (#2209132)
"Then I must have misunderstood your point."

You still are. The core point is different people will measure things differently. The point is that what Person A sees as a minor injustice that he committed against B, B sees as a major injustice because it happened to him. There's an old quote attributed to Mel Brooks where I found it online, though the core quote has been around longer than that: "Tragedy is when I cut my finger. Comedy is when you fall down an open manhole cover and die." That's the part of my point you're missing (and I do not think merely disagreeing with), people valuate injustices that happen to them much higher than things that happen to other people, let alone their enemies. Part of why I think you can't be disagreeing with it is this is undeniably true; people are not neutrally scrupulously fair on any level when it comes to their own possessions or desires. Everybody carries around an enormous self-bias, for various reasons, not all of them even bad.

Yes, society has come to some basic agreements, but that's not relevant to my point. I explicitly stated that retaliation isn't always unjust, and for another I also explicitly said that while each side perceived its retaliation as just the net effect is an unjust spiral. The perceptions are not the same on all sides. Every major conflict in the world is between a righteous and holy side that only commits justifiable and regrettable retaliation against the bad guys who inexplicably engage in acts of pure, unadulterated evil just for the fun of it and just won't leave us alone... and this describes the beliefs of both sides. Sticking the happy side of this label on "our side" with Anonymous is not something I'm ready to do, not ready to overlook the means to their ends, however wonderful the ends may be.

And none of this is a refinement of or a contradiction of anything else I've already said, just trying to lay the same basic point out yet more clearly.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sesqu on Saturday February 12, 2011 @06:56AM (#2209877)
people valuate injustices that happen to them much higher than things that happen to other people

That doesn't matter. Sure, people do disagree on things that involve them personally, but they aren't the only ones acting. Very often, people make judgements about matters that may later involve them or people they empathize with, on either side. These future people may or may not have had previous experience with the thing, but all that is required for them to act so as to lower expected injustice is that they empathize with someone on both sides. This act can be both unjust and reduce injustice, as long as the process is ongoing (so that the expected injustices and participants materialize).

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by amadiver on Friday February 11, 2011 @09:45AM (#2206443)
> From where should a justice system derive its just powers?

One possibility is where a plurality of constituents agree either on a course of action, or believe an individual is qualified to act in their best interest. Obviously, this system has flaws (what happens when an elected person behaves selfishly?), but I'd argue it's more fair, in general, than a self-selected group executing their own agenda. We can't vote Anon out of power if we happen to stop believing their actions are just.

> Why is mob justice any worse than a justice system that allows people to be held indefinitely with out charge?

It's not, but are you insinuating that it's okay to subvert an unjust justice system using any means necessary? Or any means that work? Or am I reading into this? I don't think the US justice system is so broken that it needs to be fixed by extralegal means, but maybe I'm naive.

> Would altering or abolishing a system that allows people to be held indefinitely with out charge be a good thing?

Altering that system would be a great thing! Abolishing it, I believe, would not. If you're suggesting anarchy as a viable replacement, I'm honestly curious if you can point to any examples of large-scale anarchy that worked well? Again, I might be reading too much into your question, and you might have meant simply replacing it with another system that is not anarchy.

Thanks for your reply.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by spxdcz on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:24PM (#2205031)
Why have people downvoted fletiz's response to -1? I don't necessarily agree or disagree with it (I'm staying neutral in this discussion), but please - stop downvoting replies that you disagree with. This response, as far as I can see, was reasonable and considered.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by mbateman on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:39PM (#2205058)
I've never understood the idea that downvoting a comment for disagreeing with it is bad. Anyway, I also disagree that it's reasonable and considered. The comparisons are flip and cheap and build in false alternatives. Not all methods of altering or abolishing unjust systems are laudable, and finding anonymous to be reprehensible is compatible with agreeing that some of their targets are reprehensible also.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sesqu on Friday February 11, 2011 @01:45PM (#2207608)
Downvoting for disagreeing is bad because your brain already does that for you, and very well at that. Votes regulate eyeballs, and should be awarded to comments that give you new insights, not ones that reaffirm your existing prejudices.

If you disagree with a comment that attempts to give thought to the issue at hand, please explain why you believe those thoughts to be wrong. This will force you to consider their thoughts and help others do so as well.

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by fleitz on Thursday February 10, 2011 @10:38PM (#2205056)
It's no biggie, the reaction is quite what I expected given Plato's parable of the Cave.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d2afuTvUzBQ

Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by megablast on Friday February 11, 2011 @02:25AM (#2205493)
When talking about mob justice, don't just select for the mobs you like. Consider the brown shirts, the KKK, and other mobs, who also carried out there own versions of justice.
Re:How Aaron Barr revealed himself to Anonymous by sigzero on Thursday February 10, 2011 @11:31PM (#2205179)
What they didn't isn't "okay" not in any way shape or form.