Re:Bing smacks Google in new usability test
by gojomo on Thursday February 10, 2011 @07:47PM
(#2204635)
My greatest search success is when the information I need is in the displayed snippets. Others clearly agree: see DuckDuckGo's 'zero click info' and Google's 'One Box' results.
Next best is when the snippets make it clear I need to refine my search, rather than wasting my time wading through the result sites. Again, no clicks from the results, but a happier searcher.
So the Hitwise 'success rate' metric seems totally bogus to me – inversely correlated to the quality of snippets/OneBox.
I suspect Google's snippets are still the best in the business, though an objective analysis of that would be interesting news.
Re:Bing smacks Google in new usability test
by moultano on Thursday February 10, 2011 @08:04PM
(#2204686)
When powerset launched they had very impressive snippets. Now that they've been bought by microsoft, I wonder how much of the technology has been integrated.
Next best is when the snippets make it clear I need to refine my search, rather than wasting my time wading through the result sites. Again, no clicks from the results, but a happier searcher.
So the Hitwise 'success rate' metric seems totally bogus to me – inversely correlated to the quality of snippets/OneBox.
I suspect Google's snippets are still the best in the business, though an objective analysis of that would be interesting news.