Re:IBM's "Watson" finally ready for prime-time Jeopardy
by azakai on Thursday February 10, 2011 @09:39PM
(#2204924)
I think you are exactly right. Other commenters seem to be misunderstanding you.
It's clear that this is a huge achievement. However, it is different than a computer beating the human chess champion. All this will prove is that a computer is about the same as the best humans, not strictly better than them.
(And, that it is strictly better at timing its buzzer response, which is completely not impressive for a machine to excel at.)
Again, I fully understand and appreciate what an advance in natural language processing and sheer computation Watson represents. Even being able to match a below-average human Jeopardy! contestant would be impressive. However, the true game-winning technique in Jeopardy! (when all three contestants are highly skilled) is buzzer reflexes.