Re:Barr Asks Apple to Unlock iPhones of Pensacola Gunman
by anonu on Tuesday January 14, 2020 @11:59PM
(#22051858)
Maybe that's all true.
But can you discount a scenario where a hardware hookup and brute forces through all possible numeric security codes? Could take less than a minute. Who is to say there isn't a bypass that allows them to do this? Very hard to tell
Re:Barr Asks Apple to Unlock iPhones of Pensacola Gunman
by olliej on Wednesday January 15, 2020 @11:04AM
(#22055375)
The secure element is responsible for gating retries, and like all HSMs is designed specifically to prevent tampering, so everything - including retry counts and delays - is theoretically rendered untamperable.
I am aware of two bugs in that logic over the years - I can’t find the articles off the top of my head. One was essentially a TOCTOU bug that could be triggered via voltage spikes to reset the device after you tried to unlock but before it updated the retry count. The other required imaging and restoring the flash between each attempt. I don’t know how that was fixed, but it should hopefully be obvious that That is going to take more than a minute to brute force a 6 digit passcode.
All the existing attacks have started with at least a partially unlocked phone.