News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by rpz on Monday January 13, 2020 @09:12AM (#22034565)
In the spirit of pointing out inconsistencies...I am not a physicist, but something I've been confused about lately is why the action constant has a unit of seconds baked into it.

Feels like E = hf is an experiment with a hard coded 1 second measure time.

Why not express the relationship in terms of power?

P=uf where u is the action constant without the seconds unit hard coded. And E=utf has a variable time parameter

Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by rpz on Monday January 13, 2020 @09:42AM (#22034818)
Down votes? Care to explain? I'm just trying to learn here :)
Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by akubera on Monday January 13, 2020 @12:22PM (#22036451)
Didn't downvote, but they probably came because you asked a very tangential question to the subject.

I'll try to answer it: I think you just want to move units around so h (Planck's constant) has units of Joules instead of Joule-seconds. While this works mathematically, it doesn't really make sense physically, where we care about the energy of a photon because that's the value that is conserved (along with momentum, also relating to h) during any interaction (e.g. the quantity gained by an electron if the photon is absorbed). It really doesn't make sense to want to quantify the "power" of a photon, which doesn't have any physical meaning, in favor of a simpler constant.

You are right about the constant 'h' having a "hard-coded" 1-second built in, but so do ALL derived physical constants . If we, say, changed it to two seconds, the number would be cut in half to reflect the scale change and preserve the energy of the photon (or any action) because that does not depend on scale.

As to "why is it Joule-seconds?": that's the discovered law of nature. If the energy was proportional to frequency squared, h would be in units of J*s².

Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by rpz on Monday January 13, 2020 @02:59PM (#22038002)
Consider it this way. Suppose we all agreed to never use numerical values in the units section of an equation... then in this case we'd need a symbol for cycles in cycles per second aka Hz.

If we leaves Planck's constant as is in E=h(cycle/second), then the units would end up as Joulecycle... odd right?

That's what brought me to writing the formula as

E=utf

I guess it should really be

Delta E=u(delta t)f where u is in joules t is (seconds per cycle) and f is (cycles per second)

Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by rpz on Monday January 13, 2020 @04:27PM (#22038827)
The upshot of what I'm saying here is that I believe that each wavelength of light is delivering the same quanta of energy regardless of frequency
Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by plmu on Monday January 13, 2020 @11:55AM (#22036153)
Agree, I'm wondering too.
Re:Why the foundations of physics have not progressed for 40... by tlb on Monday January 13, 2020 @12:25PM (#22036480)
h (Planck's constant) has units J*s, and f (frequency) has units 1/s. Therefore E=hf has units of Joules. E is the energy of a single photon at that frequency. It's not a measurement of power.