News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Demoted and Placed on Probation by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday January 12, 2020 @06:06PM (#22030330)
It's entirely possible, given the fallibility of both huamsn and human systems, that the claim "all the final candidates were equally well qualified" is not true.

That doesn't change the original definition of AA. Neither does a demonstration that any specific institution does things differently.

If you want to change your claim to "the first sentence precisely matches what Harvard does for undergrad admissions", I'm not going to disagree with you. But that's a very different claim than the one you made.

Re:Demoted and Placed on Probation by disagreeabletot on Sunday January 12, 2020 @06:38PM (#22030548)
From my perspective I feel proponents of AA are doing the bait and switch.

I think a lot of 'AA' in practice is similar to what is done with Harvard admissions either by deliberate design or poor incentives. For example say a business notices an incorrect distribution of employees and then decides to introduce the steelman AA policy in order to try and fix this disparity. Businesses prefer to measure outcomes over process so you end up having either implicit or explicit racial proportions as goals instead of having the 'steelman AA' process being the goal. This ends up leading to explicit racial preferences and the strawman AA as the implementation.