Re:The Newton You Didn’t Know
by woodandsteel on Monday January 13, 2020 @07:50PM
(#22040621)
Oh come on. For atoms and the shape of the earth, you know perfectly well I was referring to the contemporary ideas.
And as far as argumentation goes, there was a lot, but then it got settled. Ditto for nerve cells. In each of these cases, the argumentation was because there wasn't enough empirical data to decide the matter. But then more empirical evidence got collected and the truth became clear.
The fact is, while scientists sometimes talk about nothing being really proven, in practice they believe an enormous and ever-expanding number of ideas actually are.
Neither is the earth spherical, if that's what you mean by round. It is oblate.
There has been quite a bit of argumentation along these lines in the sciences. And yes, the arguments were dismissed out of hand until evidence was forthcoming.
That's why newton's ideas about electrical vibrations in nerve cells were dismissed out of hand. After all, scientists knew with great certainty that nerves were "too flaccid" to support vibration!