For instance, there's worry that life extension will vastly worsen economic inequality. Another problem is that a lot systems in society (e.g. retirement, insurance) is implicitly based on current average lifespan, and a sudden extension of it could cause such shockwaves in the economy that it would create more suffering than it would save.
I mention these two because I acknowledge them as real risks, but despite them, I'm 100% in support of life extension. I sincerely hope that one day humans will be able to extends life indefinitely, while retaining full capacity (i.e. no everlasting life in a body of a 90-years-old).
I sure hope so.
But, to take your line of thinking further, what are the odds that we are currently at just the right lifespan for humans? If you are against increasing human lifespan, you should also probably be in favor of decreasing it, unless you think we are at very special point in time in entire human history.
I am also seeking to understand if others feel as I do on this subject.
To even Aknowledge that it might be possible could lead to false hope and disappointment. I think thats the main reason many people are instinctively against it
The mind basically tries to protect them from fighting against the impossible and earning nothing but dread and disappointment.
Religion perpetuated the notion that living is inherently better than death despite suffering and we are stuck with it everywhere.
Rationally, is it true that someone can be better off dead? No. For something to be better, it requires comparison of former with later state. Since you won't exist, there is no state to compare. No one dead can feel sadness. (of course that's relying on there being no after life or reincarnation)
Flip that switch, is it true someone can be better off living? No. For the same reason, you have to presume continued existence is good since you can't rely on comparing states.
How do you know continued existence will be good or better?
That you can't. You can make a guess based on data relying on hedonism but that's all there is. No one agrees on what good continued existence is either so people in part are using their experience and values to judge which doesn't make sense if you allow individuals to have freedom of deciding their own values and life.
I say, we stop extending life expectancy and focus on cutting off the problems that make existing existence a pain even if for majority, happiness or society outweigh it. There are many useless things people waste their life on currently, why do they need to?
Am I quite alone in this?