News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by azangru on Friday January 10, 2020 @03:20AM (#22009345)
> I have a PhD in physics. I have zero problem with anyone downloading any of my papers from scihub.

Out of curiosity: why don't you just host your papers on your website then - or, if you do, why don't you think it's enough?

Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by martin_vejmelka on Friday January 10, 2020 @03:50AM (#22009472)
> why don't you just host your papers on your website then - or, if you do, why don't you think it's enough?

Most publishers prevented you from doing this as of a few years ago (I left academic research around that time). You were not allowed to post any content that contains any work by the publisher (even formatting/editing changes after first round of reviews). Thus you could only publish a "preprint" which no-one can rely on to cite because they don't know what's in the final peer-reviewed version. Some publishers are more lenient than others but there's definitely friction induced.

Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by improbable22 on Friday January 10, 2020 @04:03AM (#22009519)
The norm at least in parts of physics is to update the arxiv version once the paper is accepted, with a note saying "v3: matches version to appear in XXX", with a DOI link. Where "matches" means the content, but not the journal's formatting, spelling & comma preferences, etc.

(And ideally this note would also mention any substantial changes, like "new section 4 explaining..." or "derivation in 3.2 re-written, but no change to conclusions", for the benefit of those who already read v2.)

Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by neffy on Friday January 10, 2020 @07:14AM (#22010422)
I do the same (over in comp sci.) - usually the journals will let you put pre-print articles up on arxiv, researchgate, and web pages, and then the final article - sometimes with added spelling mistakes - many of the journals have off shored the editorial process - is on their site.
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by frenchyatwork on Friday January 10, 2020 @11:45AM (#22012242)
I'm curious what would happen if a new paper tried to reference previous papers published in ArXiv instead of the traditional publishers. From a strictly academic perspective, I can't think of any reason why this would be a problem, apart from the existential problem it causes for traditional publishers.
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by improbable22 on Friday January 10, 2020 @03:14PM (#22014962)
Citing papers which aren't yet published by their arxiv numbers is routine. (And, before 1991, people did the same using the author's institute's preprint numbers.) If they have appeared in a journal by the time yours is accepted by a journal, then you should add the journal info too. (Although many journals now allow you to leave the arxiv numbers as an additional part of each reference.)
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by jhrmnn on Friday January 10, 2020 @06:22AM (#22010210)
I (not OP) do, https://jan.hermann.name/publications/ (note the copyright notices, required by the journals, which pop up when you hover of the pdf link [didn't figure out a good alternative on mobile]). In rare cases, the journals don't allow this at all, in some cases they allow you to self-publish only the submitted manuscript, before any modifications based on peer review.

As for why it's not enough—because hiring committees and funding agencies almost never take unpublished (that is, in a proper journal) manuscripts into account when evaluating you and your funding proposals. This is what needs to change in the first place to break the loop.

Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by lrem on Friday January 10, 2020 @03:26AM (#22009374)
Many (most?) do, that's where Google Scholar took its PDFs from pre-scihub.
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by lorenzhs on Friday January 10, 2020 @04:17AM (#22009584)
Google Scholar still gets its PDFs from preprint servers and author's websites. I suppose you meant to say that Google Scholar's web indexing is how many people got their PDFs pre-scihub?
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by lrem on Friday January 10, 2020 @05:04AM (#22009856)
Yes, you managed to unmangle my pre-coffee reply attempt correctly :)
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by gewa on Friday January 10, 2020 @03:44AM (#22009446)
Im not sure if it's legally flawless to upload the published journal article to your Website and open it up to the public. As far as i know, you're only allowed to pass it on a personal, per-request basis. This explicitly refers to the final peer reviewed article and not to the manuscript, which can make a great difference.
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by prepend on Friday January 10, 2020 @08:52AM (#22010877)
It’s granted individually on a personal, per http request.
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by Thrymr on Friday January 10, 2020 @11:12AM (#22011961)
Many publishers explicitly allow you to post your own articles on your personal/professional website. Some only allow "preprint" form and not the published version.
Re:The Unstoppable Rise of Sci-Hub (2019) by semi-extrinsic on Friday January 10, 2020 @11:43AM (#22012224)
Most journals explicitly allow preprints or postprints (the final article, but without the layout of the publisher) to be posted on personal webpages.