News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:MT9: An mp3 replacement? by jws on Tuesday June 17, 2008 @03:36PM (#220062)
To replace mp3 you need to win on at least one of these fronts:

  * licensing/royalties
  * quality per bit
  * power consumption to decode
The article addresses none of these, but instead talks about being able to remix an song to suit your tastes because all of the instruments are on different tracks.

This is just silly. Rounded to one percent, no one wants to do this to their music. Add to that, it isn't really possible because in any modern musical production there is audio processing that happens to groups of tracks on the way to a final mix and then more processing on all of the tracks combined. The final product is not a linear combination of the inputs.

A poorly thought out gimmicky feature is not going to replace mp3.

Oh, the labels will have to support it since it will require completely new production techniques and if the cost doesn't cause them an aneurism then the idea that you can go in and rip out a drum line to sample will.

Re:MT9: An mp3 replacement? by hernan7 on Tuesday June 17, 2008 @04:24PM (#220097)
Also, for the few of us that might want to remix a track, a limit of 6 tracks is grossly inadequate.
Re:MT9: An mp3 replacement? by jrockway on Tuesday June 17, 2008 @05:35PM (#220162)
Definitely. For example, a lot of music I like has clipped peaks so that the bulk of the song sounds louder on the radio. If that's the game they want to play, fine... but when I'm at home on my expensive audio system, I want the un-clipped version. I already like your music, so you don't have to market to me anymore. If I want it to be loud, I will turn up the volume. </rant>