Re:Ask HN: How many of you are rolling your own auth?
by anderspitman on Thursday January 09, 2020 @06:51PM
(#22007145)
Awesome, thanks for this. I think I've read the Road to Hell article 3/4 times at this point. It makes a little more sense each time as I learn more.
I totally agree there are so many resources about implementation, and honestly it's pretty straight forward. My guess is that because of this people don't think to question it and simply assume it's all necessary. And maybe it is, but in my experience necessity is often tied to specific assumptions that may not be true for a specific use case.
With oauth in particular I suspect a lot of the details are tied to the assumption that you have to do a full redirect in order to authenticate. But my emauth.io service uses email over a back-channel to authenticate, so the user can stay on the app page while they verify their identity. So at the very least you don't have to worry about redirect hijacking.
Also not a good resource, but acceptable: Pluralsight. There is one straight up OAuth course to go over all the basics and then quite a few language/framework specific ones, e.g. how to implement OAuth in Node/ASP.NET/etc. The OAuth course was dry but had some decent information - but I did quit halfway through it because of IdentityServer, so take that with a grain of salt.
And yes, it sure does feel more complicated than it has any right to be. There's a good read here https://hueniverse.com/oauth-2-0-and-the-road-to-hell-8eec45... by the once-lead-author.
I really do recommend checking out IdentityServer4 though, unless you're implementing this specifically to learn / have fun / etc. And if you don't care for the Microsoft ecosystem, I've heard nice things about Hydra https://github.com/ory/hydra which is a similar Go offering.