News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by DanI-S on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @08:04PM (#2200153)
I love Nokia's hardware, and have great respect for Microsoft's mobile team. But I'm not sure whether two dinosaurs together can run faster than one.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by jacabado on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @08:28PM (#2200236)
What is the track record of Microsoft in this kind of partnerships?

Genuine question.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by SwellJoe on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @09:38PM (#2200447)
You'd have to define "this kind of partnership". There are a number of mobile device makers building Windows phones. And there have been many co-development and branding deals over the years with Microsoft and PC makers. Many have been successful, many have failed.

This, however, brings to mind the OS/2 deal, to me. If Microsoft culture is anything like it was in the 90s (which may not be the case), I would expect Microsoft to be a loyal partner with Nokia until such time as it is advantageous for them to go their own way, leaving Nokia holding the bag on a jointly developed "standard" platform that no one else wants.

But, hey, I'm a cynical old nerd that's been involved in technology too long. The fact that Microsoft is a distant third, and losing ground daily, in the market might make a difference in how they treat their friends.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by brudgers on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:12PM (#2200532)
The supposed Microsoft Nokia partnership isn't joint development of a phone OS. It looks more likely that Nokia could get out of the OS business altogether.

I'm not sure that OS/2 is the best analogy. That wasn't a hardware company and software company teaming up. And it is unlikely that Nokia and Microsoft will evolve to become direct competitors in the way IBM and Microsoft did in the late 1980's and early 90's.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by SwellJoe on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:30PM (#2200604)
"I'm not sure that OS/2 is the best analogy. That wasn't a hardware company and software company teaming up."

I can't make any sense of this statement. IBM was the definitive hardware company at the time. Microsoft was the definitive software company at the time. What kind of companies do you think they were?

"The supposed Microsoft Nokia partnership isn't joint development of a phone OS."

As far as I can tell, we have no idea what sort of partnership they have in mind. But, I would expect Nokia to want a unique value, if they build Windows phones. And they have a huge development workforce, and have made numerous software acquisitions over the years. I'd be surprised if they don't plan to write some code, too.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by philwelch on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:56PM (#2200689)
IBM was a systems company, not a hardware company. The difference is that a hardware company doesn't, by and large, develop their own software.

Apple is another example of a systems company.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by SwellJoe on Thursday February 10, 2011 @12:09AM (#2200878)
"IBM was a systems company, not a hardware company. The difference is that a hardware company doesn't, by and large, develop their own software."

You can't have it both ways. Nokia makes the vast majority of their own software and has for years. They have a huge software development staff, and have acquired a number of major software shops to augment it.

And, while we're on the subject, in the PC market, IBM did not, by and large, develop their own software. They contracted out to Microsoft to make the OS in the beginning, and then teamed up with them to make OS/2. So, technically, I guess you can't compare the two because Nokia makes a lot more of the software on its devices than IBM made on its early PCs. But, that's the opposite of the argument you've made above.

I don't think it really matters, though. I think this is a mistake for Nokia, and I think time will bear that assertion out.

And, of course, if you don't like the IBM and OS/2 comparison, how about SGI and Windows NT? That was a unique relationship between a hardware (and software) company and Microsoft that had disastrous consequences for SGI.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by philwelch on Thursday February 10, 2011 @01:22AM (#2201034)
Nokia makes the vast majority of their own software and has for years.

Hence the premise, "It looks more likely that Nokia could get out of the OS business altogether". Without that premise; yes, Nokia is obviously IBM. So question that premise rather than the validity of the argument, if that's your intention. I myself think it's a shaky premise, but given that premise, Nokia isn't IBM.

And, while we're on the subject, in the PC market, IBM did not, by and large, develop their own software

IBM had literally decades of experience developing their own software for every other type of computer before PC's even existed. Likewise, Nokia has decades of experience developing embedded software for cellular phones. Has Nokia matched iOS or Android yet? No, and neither had IBM matched the Apple II.

The company-defining question is where one goes from there--IBM adopted DOS as a stopgap but quickly worked to develop OS/2, first with Microsoft and then without them (hence attempting--and failing--to remain a systems company). Nokia has attempted to develop Symbian, but if they drop Symbian and decide to adopt Windows Phone (which, again, was expressly the premise of that comment), they would move in the opposite direction, like Tandy did.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by Kylekramer on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @08:52PM (#2200327)
There is a reason the term "Wintel" was created. But I'd bet they can't pull it off again.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by PakG1 on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:37PM (#2200621)
I think the primary point would be that Wintel created a brand new market that hadn't yet really been developed yet. This time around (if it really happens), they're attacking a market that's pretty well developed. Still growing, but by no means at an infant stage.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by philwelch on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:58PM (#2200696)
The distinction between "a brand new market that hasn't yet really been developed yet" and a market that's "well developed [but] still growing" can only be drawn in retrospect. Wintel was a decade late to personal computers, but it turns out a decade late was early enough.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by PakG1 on Thursday February 10, 2011 @01:07AM (#2201006)
Fair enough. But I'd also say the key metric to analyze would be market penetration, percentage of total population buying the products. A lot more people have cell phones these days, both percentage-wise and gross numbers-wise, than people had personal computers back in the day.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by asmithmd1 on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @09:30PM (#2200423)
or two drunks tied together will walk in a straight line
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by StavrosK on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @09:31PM (#2200428)
You know, I bet two drunks tied together would be way more stable than one. Four legs are better than two.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by philwelch on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:52PM (#2200673)
Two drunks tied together don't make four legs. They make two legs vs. two legs.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by electromagnetic on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @11:20PM (#2200754)
I'm with you on that, I expect the probability of 'drunks tied together' falling down to increase following the square-cube law.

I have a similar theory that the reason female washrooms always seem to have too few stalls is because their is a square-law going on. Ever notice how when your wife/girlfriend/friend goes to the washroom on their own they take roughly the same time as a guy, but when they go with their friend they easily take double the time it would for two guys, even assuming only one stall available. This is my reasoning on why buildings increase the number of washrooms rather than simply expanding on the one despite the extra washrooms usually being in inconvenient locations.

I think somewhere some architect built a banquet hall with a 100 stall female washroom and at a function all the women knew each other, meaning they spent like two-weeks in the washroom and resorted to cannibalism.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by allwein on Thursday February 10, 2011 @12:47PM (#2202844)
>I'm with you on that, I expect the probability of 'drunks tied together' falling down to increase following the square-cube law.

I think this is true only up to a point. I imagine that once you get a sufficient number of drunks, that you can simply tie them together tight enough that they'd stay standing like a shock of wheat.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by philwelch on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @11:37PM (#2200794)
Female washrooms also have queueing inefficiencies compared to male washrooms. Women need a stall no matter what, men only need a stall in some cases and a urinal for other cases. And urinals have much higher throughput.
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by r00fus on Thursday February 10, 2011 @02:28AM (#2201160)
Not to mention, when push comes to shove, a guy can urinate pretty much anywhere. I remember back in my college days when I'd go to the bar restroom and the stalls were being used, the urinal was in use, a guy was peeing in the trash can and another dude was using the sink...
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by madmath on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @08:41PM (#2200283)
I could imagine Nokia becoming just a phone hardware manufacturer (many have pointed out that they have great hardware) like LG or HTC, and integrate software from companies such as Microsoft. If Samsung, LG, HTC do it, how hard can it be?
Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by brown on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @09:08PM (#2200367)
Nokia doesn't want that though. Nokia leadership views "just a phone hardware manufacturer" as a doomed fate in a commodity business, much like PC manufacturers have been a commodity for the past 10-20 years. Granted, Dell has done alright in that space, but overall that market still represents a commoditized business.

Instead, Nokia wants to control the stack. That means having an integrated hardware + software solution. That creates real competitive advantage, which creates real profits. Apple has 25% margins. Dell has single digit margins.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by JulianMorrison on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @09:33PM (#2200431)
No-one else can be Apple. It's questionable how long Apple can continue to be Apple. They got to own a stack because they started way ahead of the competition and haven't slacked or hit any technological walls. Upon the inevitable moment they lose momentum, the clones baying at their heels will eat them. This happened before, with classic Mac before the Jobs renaissance.

As for Nokia, the market has reached a point of consolidation on standards comparable to the collapse of competing computer types in the early 90s from Atari, Commodore, Acorn, Amstrad etc to PC and Mac and nothing else. So they can either sell hardware or die.

Re:Nokia Is Said to Be Near Software Partnership With Microsoft by PakG1 on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:44PM (#2200644)
It's interesting to note that Apple was in a very similar position back in those days. They were dying, and made the decision to buy NeXT to change OS directions. The primary consideration was the OS, not Jobs; they were apparently very close to buying BeOS instead. Jobs being the catalyst for strategic change happened to be a pleasant surprise. He didn't even become the CEO of Apple again until much later.

So, to be clear, even Apple wasn't Apple. Apple didn't reinvent itself. Apple bought NeXT to try to go a new direction; that is, innovation was acquired, not developed in-house. Looks like Nokia would be forced to do the same, judging from the mood around meego (or in this case, simply partner with an outsider).