Re:Google files opening Supreme Court brief in Oracle v. Goo...
by pgsbathhouse on Saturday January 11, 2020 @07:13PM
(#22023413)
>copying implementation code vs copying an API
You said code. Not implementation code.
The appeal courts reversal of Alsups decision in 2014 was on the basis of copying the API. They wrote "that the overall structure of Oracle's API packages is creative, original, and resembles a taxonomy"[0].
You're conflating two separate issues, copying implementation code vs copying an API -- copying the implementation was resolved in 2012. Copying the API is still being litigated. If you have a docket or ruling or source that says otherwise, then of course feel free to list it.
Or if you want to make the argument that declarative headers for an API are technically code, then... OK, whatever, fine. But it's still wildly deceptive to conflate declarative code and implementation code without mentioning that the law has treated them separately for decades. You're making it sound to a normal reader like Google wholesale lifted implementation logic from Java, which is just not what happened.
[0]: https://www.leagle.com/decision/infco20140509135