News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What people get wrong about Bertrand Russell by kazinator on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:38AM (#21989190)
An undecidable proposition is true in the logical sense if we declare it true and adopt it as an axiom.

It might seem that it's not true in that logical way which insists that truth is derived from existing axiom. But that concept depends on unproven axioms in the first place, and derivation can be a zero-step process.

That is to say the axiom we have added is now derived from an existing axiom (itself) by an empty sequence of logical steps.

Re:What people get wrong about Bertrand Russell by fatbird on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @11:40AM (#21992990)
How do you find that undecidable proposition? You derive it from axioms. You can't declare it axiomatic if you can't find it because it's undecidable.

The big idea that the Incompleteness Theorem torpedoed was that it's possible to enumerate all and only those theorems that are true/provable for a given set of axioms. To get all of them, you must allow unprovable theorems; to eliminate the unprovable ones, you'll necessarily also eliminate some provable theorems. It's Heisenberg's Uncertainty Principle for logic, and it was exactly that destructive to logical determinism/positivism.