News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by yongjik on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:09AM (#21988804)
I don't think x86 compatibility mattered. When it launched in 2001 it was supposed to replace HP's PA-RISC architecture which is totally different anyway. Sun and its SPARC processors were very much alive, Google was only three years old, and AWS was five years away - the idea that a massive array of cheap x86 processors will outperform enterprise-class servers simply hadn't occurred to most people yet.

Of course, the joke is that cheap x86 processors did outperform Itanium (and every other architectures, eventually).

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by kragen on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:06AM (#21989039)
> When it launched in 2001...the idea that a massive array of cheap x86 processors will outperform enterprise-class servers simply hadn't occurred to most people yet

When do you mean? In 2001?

It occurred to Yahoo, whose site had been run that way since almost the beginning, on FreeBSD. It occurred to Google, whose site was run that way since the beginning. It occurred to anyone who was watching the Top500 list, which was already crawling with Beowulfs — admittedly, not at the top of the list yet. It should have occurred to Intel, who were presumably the ones selling those servers to Yahoo and Penguin Computing and VA Research (who had IPOed in 1999 under the symbol LNUX). It had occurred to Intergraph, who had switched from their own high-performance graphics chips to Intel's by 1998. It had occurred to Jim Clark, who had jumped off the sinking MIPS ship at SGI. In 1994. It occurred to the rest of SGI by 1998, when they launched the SGI Visual Workstation, then announced they were going to give up on MIPS and board the Itanic.

I mean, yes, it hadn't occurred to most people yet. Because most people are stupid, and most of the ones who weren't stupid weren't paying attention. But it hadn't occurred to most people at Intel? You'd think they'd have a pretty good handle on how much ass they were already kicking.

> the joke is that cheap x86 processors did outperform Itanium (and every other architectures, eventually).

Even on my Intel laptop, more of the computrons come from the Intel integrated GPU. In machines with ATI (cough) and NVIDIA cards, it's no contest; the GPU is an order of magnitude beefier.

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by scholia on Thursday January 09, 2020 @08:33AM (#22001001)
> When it launched in 2001...the idea that a massive array of cheap x86 processors will outperform enterprise-class servers simply hadn't occurred to most people yet

The idea was certainly around in the early-to-mid 1980s, when some former Intel engineers founded Sequent.

The Balance 8000, released in 1984, supported up to 12 processors on dual-CPU boards, while the Balance 21000, released in 1986, supported up to 30.

I interviewed the founder, Casey Powell, and he was explicit about multiple Intel microprocessors replacing large systems. He was targeting minicomputers at the time, of course, but we all anticipated that bigger sets of more powerful CPUs would eventually surpass even the biggest "big iron".

Powell was a great guy. However, his company got taken over by IBM. In the end, he didn't get to change the world.

"It's hard to be the little guy on the block and have really great technology and get beaten, just because the other guy is big." https://www.cnet.com/news/sequent-was-overmatched-ceo-says/

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by kragen on Thursday January 09, 2020 @12:05PM (#22003001)
Right! Some friends of mine spent a lot of time programming a Symmetry in the early 1990s. Also around the same time, 1988, Sun introduced the Sun386i, which could even run multiple MS-DOS programs at once — but it wasn't a huge success, and they stuck with SPARC. I think Sequent and the Sun386i were just too early, say by about six or seven years.

An interesting question is: what are the structural advantages of bigness? When Control Data produced the world's fastest computer, some people at IBM wondered how it could happen that a much smaller company could beat them to the punch that way; others believed that that smallness was precisely the reason.

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by AnimalMuppet on Thursday January 09, 2020 @01:14PM (#22003792)
The advantage of smallness is that you can be faster than the big guys. You also can go into smaller niches.

The advantages of bigness are that you can use scale to make the same thing less expensive, and that you can make at least one mistake without it killing you, and that you can chase more than one "next big things" at once.

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by rbanffy on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @11:12AM (#21992665)
> I don't think x86 compatibility mattered.

It did. At that time Linux and open source were not the clear winners in the server space they are now and people were not used (or able) to recompile their code.

Windows took a long time to support Itanium and companies wouldn't buy it because they had nothing to run on those machines. They got x86 machines instead and amd64 when it became available.

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by xscott on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @01:56AM (#21989007)
> I don't think x86 compatibility mattered.

I'll admit I had a limited worldview, but not running Excel as quickly seemed like the kind of criticisms I saw in the trade rags at the time.

> the idea that a massive array of cheap x86 processors will outperform enterprise-class servers simply hadn't occurred to most people yet

Oh, I don't know. There was a really common Slashdot cliche running around at that time: "Can you imagine a Beowulf cluster of these?"

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by kragen on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @02:07AM (#21989045)
Yeah, it had clearly occurred to everyone on Slashdot. On the other hand, we liked to "imagine Beowulf clusters" of all kinds of recondite hardware. Elbrus 2000 is real power!

HOT GRITS!

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by bloopernova on Thursday January 09, 2020 @10:44AM (#22002087)
/. was another world, one that I miss sometimes. I'm probably viewing it through rose-tinted nostalgia, but I don't remember the vitriol and hatred that so many social sites are soaked in these days.

The Mozilla open source announcement, the Microsoft anti-trust case, Linux exploding in popularity, it all felt like we were changing the world for the better.

Re:Which Machines Do Computer Architects Admire? (2013) by AnimalMuppet on Thursday January 09, 2020 @01:28PM (#22003926)
/. was great... and then it wasn't. The troll population went way up, the "first post" thing was just noise, and eventually I just quit going there.

HN is also less than it used to be, but I think that the mods have kept it better than /. became - so far, at least.