News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by slenk on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @04:56PM (#21985410)
> “As a pilot, my eye is always on safety first,” FAA Administrator Steve Dickson said in a statement Thursday announcing the rule. “Safety is a joint responsibility between government, pilots, the drone community, the general public and many others who make our nation so creative and innovative.”

How does this make it any more safe? People are still going to fly where they aren't supposed to and in ways that aren't safe, and this rule won't change a thing in those regards.

If you're currently using a drone to fly over downtown LA illegally and take shots, why in the world would you put identifying information on it?

I would also like to know what private companies are getting all this money to implement a new system? Could they have any ties to individuals within the FAA? The Commercial Drone Alliance has also been pushing hard, presumably since it is trying to keep its commercial partners the only operators that can fly.

To me, the fact they are saying this is for safety, is a very VERY thin argument.

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by bjt2n3904 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:06PM (#21985555)
It's pretty simple... registration systems like this don't actually make anyone safer, they just make people feel safer because they get to exert some minuscule amount of control.
Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by CrazyStat on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:17PM (#21985681)
> If you're currently using a drone to fly over downtown LA illegally and take shots, why in the world would you put identifying information on it?

Because the proposed regulations make it illegal to sell drones that don't identify themselves.

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by slenk on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:30PM (#21985828)
Build your own. It's easy. I've built 2 myself and have learned from/taught some of my friends.

I have registered myself with the FAA for their current program, but I know plenty of people that haven't.

Nor do I want to have to figure out what I need for a TinyWhoop or similar because every little bit of weight is important at that size.

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by 0_____0 on Wednesday January 08, 2020 @04:31AM (#21989841)
99% of the people flying drones in unsafe or harrassing ways have an off-the-shelf camera quad. The DIY operators are far more likely to understand the ramifications of what they're doing, maybe because you have to have just a bit of common sense to build one in the first place.

Credentials: raced 250 class quads (poorly), have chewed Phantom operators out for doing stupid shit

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by jedberg on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:41PM (#21985937)
You can build your own car and drive it around on the streets without a license plate (or license), but you won't get very far.
Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by slenk on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:49PM (#21986030)
Yeah if you drive in a busy city. But if you build a car on your farmland and want to have fun, do whatever you want. And in most states, if its private property, that is perfectly legal.

Likewise, if I am flying a drone in middle-of-nowhere Michigan on my own property, why should the FAA care what I am doing?

The problem with the FAA rules is that it is a poorly thought out blanket statement. If you are flying around downtown LA, yes, you should have a license because you are putting people's lives at danger with a "vehicle".

They don't make sense to me on private property, and I think that they should be different depending on city limits.

If we get into some of the autonomous aspects that both cars and drones have, I think we run into some other gray areas where a blanket policy doesn't fit.

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by AWildC182 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:32PM (#21985846)
Building drones is stupid easy. It doesn't even need to be a quadcopter, you can make a glider that will stay aloft on thermals using nothing more than two servos, some foam core, some AA batteries and a receiver.

This seems dumb...

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by jedberg on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:43PM (#21985959)
It's for safety the same way a license plate is for safety. If you're using an illegal drone without ID, that automatically makes you suspicious.

If you can't follow that simple rule, what other rules are you not following?

It allows enforcement to be target at those who are so obviously not following the rules, while at the same time encouraging everyone else to follow the rules since their drone will be easy to identify.

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by bjt2n3904 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:59PM (#21986148)
License plates don't stop drunk drivers, speeding, or other reckless behavior. It doesn't make you wear a seatbelt, either.

License plates aren't for safety. They're so we can more easily charge road tolls, parking fines, and increasingly: keep tabs on people's whereabouts.

Effectively, drone registration is much the same -- except it would be a better analogy to say the DMV wants everyone to get license plates on bicycles and scooters. (Small vehicle, readily built from parts off the internet, people who enjoy them are generally seen as a nuisance, and this legislation simply gives them an additional burden as a middle finger.)

Re:Proposed FAA Rule Would Kickstart New Economy for IDing D... by slenk on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @05:54PM (#21986076)
But this won't easily allow the general public to see that someone is unsafe; there are no visual indicators.

So, while with license plates pedestrians can call in and report a car without a license plate, a drone won't be identifiable one way or the other.