I don't want to be acquired by them, but I have much more respect for shops like Thoma Bravo that act as operators and acquire strategically for portfolio companies that places like Bain, for example.
There are a lot of bad players or stupid businessmen and politicians in municipalities who have given it a bad name by making dumb exploitative deals. Which I do not condone or wish to defend.
But PE has still done a lot of good turn arounds and has been proven via plenty of data to be a net-gain in terms of its economic contribution to society, saving plenty of jobs and American companies that were headed for certain death.
Companies within all industries always vary in quality, but I think it's silly and dangerous to define entire industries merely by a small group of it's worst players - like the way people have been trying to pin the entire Silicon Valley industry to Ubers and Theranos, or Google/FB acting poorly, despite is otherwise countless success stories.
This sort of thinking, political spin, and media coverage is what creates destructive gov policies aimed at the few small minority of big bad guys but often ultimately just harms the other 90% of mostly harmless good guys with needless hoop jumping or straight up banning of otherwise useful contributions to society (which there have been countless examples of such self-destructive - but of course well intentioned - policies driven by similar emotional reactionaryism).
PE has been a punching bag for a long time. My only wish is that it is done rationally and using an evidence based approach. Politics has a habit of stirring up hysteria with stuff like this, disconnecting it from the reality on the ground, which LBOs and PE certainly has a longstanding legacy of, which you can see thoroughly in this thread. It's hardly new. But yes of course it is an industry notorious for its leeches and one that should be treated carefully, not with white gloves.
Just remember the worst stories take up 90% of the headlines, the countless successful ones often happen quietly, or in less read retrospectives or books. The stuff that rarely tops Reddit or HN, so it's easy to assume that all companies doing LBO are evil blood sucking monsters if you don't pay close attention.
A huge fraction of increased profitability comes from the fact that interest payments are tax deductible while dividends aren't, so LBOs artificially reduce costs. Rearranging debt obligations can break free up cash by dodging severance and retirement expenses. And the ability to recoup losses via unsustainable, high-margin practices encourages PE firms to pursue riskier turnaround approaches, then brag about their success rates while failing to acknowledge that their failures are often more damaging than gradual, non-PE-driven ones.
"Alive or dead" may be easy to measure, but the impact on people isn't binary; PE tactics for raising the survival rate largely come at the cost of worse outcomes in both cases. And the cases where PE is straightforwardly beneficial are usually the least-troubled firms, where it's acting more like investment and tax reduction.
Private equity firms aren't all just corporate raiders of the 1980s that certain politicians try to spin them as.
That's not to say that small towns selling off public services to them is a good idea. Or any other public/private partnership bullshit that is sold as 'free markets' when its the mostly just politicians and their wealthy connections being complete vultures creating things that are nothing like markets.
The book "King of Capital" has a really good overview of the history of private equity:
https://www.amazon.com/King-Capital-Remarkable-Schwarzman-Bl...