News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UBS Whistleblower Finds Himself in Federal Prison by rbanffy on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:15AM (#2197623)
> Taking on a fiduciary duty of loyalty and confidence, and then breaching it... that's serious.

Lets imagine it's not about tax fraud, but, say, murder. You are a psychiatrist and your patient proves you he has murdered someone and states he intends to murder someone else.

What is more important? Your duty towards your patient or your duty towards society?

Re:UBS Whistleblower Finds Himself in Federal Prison by lionhearted on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:20AM (#2197653)
Three points -

1. He didn't report a specific crime, he dumped a bunch of data, some potentially criminal and some not.

2. The clients hadn't broken Swiss law, which is where he was employed and where he took his duty oaths.

3. Actually, your lawyer can't be compelled to testify against you even if you tell him you did commit murder. Swiss society believes that a man's relationship with his banker should be sacred. This guy agreed to that relationship in Switzerland. Then broke it.

I'm not even saying it's wrong. Just that it's worth thinking about, because it's not clear cut at all.

Re:UBS Whistleblower Finds Himself in Federal Prison by infinite8s on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @04:43PM (#2199479)
Just to address point 3, your lawyer is compelled to break priveledge if you discuss a plan to commit murder (or another crime). The situation in this regard is similar, since his clients were committing on-going fraud.
Re:UBS Whistleblower Finds Himself in Federal Prison by rbanffy on Wednesday February 09, 2011 @10:31AM (#2197686)
> because it's not clear cut at all.

Certainly not. But tax evasion is an offense more serious than people usually think.