That said, it's certainly possible to run an orderly taxation system with information that's publicly available - the more you require people to report their affairs to the authorities, the more chance of abuse you have. I'm personally of the belief that the sanest form of taxation is taxing assets held in a jurisdiction - then you're paying directly for what's protected. So tax property, and owned stocks and bonds perhaps. If you need someone to report all the money they have outside of your jurisdiction, everywhere, well I think that gets kind of scary.
Anyways, good discussion - armed thugs doesn't make for smart conversation, but good analysis overall.
You can characterize any political position you don't like with emotional language, but it makes it harder to get to truth. You did write some really good points, that's why I thought it was a shame that the emotional language comes in... it's possible to do without it.
Most people feel emotionally about their politics, but emotional language rallies your side at the expense of alienating the other side, and then discussion breaks down.
As for rhetoric, I didn't come up with the idea that your relationship with your banker should be private - that's actually how it worked in classical banking. Switzerland inherited it because they've had the longest continuous government in the world - it dates back to the Middle Ages.
The idea today that your banker and you don't have a relationship like your lawyer and you... honestly, I think classical banking is far more of an honest profession than modern law, but I'm not a huge fan of modern banking either.
Anyways, good discussing and best wishes.
I do understand resentment towards some of the financial engineering that occurred in the past fifteen years, especially in areas of exotic securitization in which systemic risks were made opaque.
But that has very little to do with classical banking. To say they have little intrinsic worth is essentially to claim that the industry that governs the allocation of credit in our economy -- that is, the credit line that finances my business's inventory and receivables, the loan that finances my new production equipment, the reasonable mortgage extended so a homeowner can buy a house, along with a substantial downpayment -- is of little use. That's an absurd position, and I don't know how one can reasonably claim that such an important function in our economy is not a respectable profession. My own company, which employs over 100 people, would immediately shut down without bank financing.
Are you confusing the practices of exotic finance, which arguably have a lesser or questionable value to society, with traditional banking?
I don't think anybody here is against that. I do recall that not too recently some not so classical banking organizations received billions upon billions of public funds to rescue them from their mistakes.
Perhaps that might be a cause for revulsion?
Watch this, it's awesome:
The Secret of Oz http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7qIhDdST27g
Quotes:
"What can government do? The sad answer is -- under the current monetary system -- nothing. It's not going to get better until the root of the problem is understood and addressed. There isn't enough stimulus money in the entire world to get us out of this hole.
"Why? Debt. The national debt is just like our consumer debt -- it's the interest that's killing us.
"Though most people don't realize it the government can't just issue it's own money anymore. It used to be that way. The King could just issue stuff called money. Abraham Lincoln did it to win the Civil War.
"No, today, in our crazy money system, the government has to borrow our money into existence and then pay interest on it. That's why they call it the National Debt. All our money is created out of debt. Politicians who focus on reducing the National Debt as an answer probably don't know what the National Debt really is. To reduce the National Debt would be to reduce our money -- and there's already too little of that.
"No, you have to go deeper. You have to get at the root of this problem or we're never going to fix this. The solution isn't new or radical. America used to do it. Politicians used to fight with big bankers over it. It's all in our history -- now sadly -- in the distant past.
"But why can't we just do it again? Why can't we just issue our own money, debt free? That, my friends, is the answer. Talk about reform! That's the only reform that will make a huge difference to everyone's life -- even worldwide.
"The solution is the secret that's been hidden from us for just over 100 years -- ever since the time when author L. Frank Baum wrote "The Wonderful Wizard of Oz."
If we had a mechanism that improved states, that worked reliably in changing oppressive governments, I'd support it. I don't think we have such a mechanism, though.
In short, I support improving states where possible, I deplore bad states, and I think the alternatives to states that we have thus far seen in history are worse than states.
Somalia isn't anarchy. It's several states, some of which are very bad (Islamic theocracies and kleptocracies). That said, it's unclear that Somalia's current set of several competing governments is worse than the single government they had before, or worse than Somalia's neighbors.
even the link you provide begins with:
Could anarchy be good for Somalia’s development?
yet you still would argue to the contrary - that lawless warlords-dominated failed state isn't anarchy?
You also seem unaware of Somaliland (one of the countries Somalia split into), which is closer to a republic (not a fully representative one) than a "warlord dominated" state. The Mujahadeen region (before they were conquered) was also rather far from a warlord dominated state (they were an Islamist theocracy).
Now as far as I know there's absolutely no state-wide rule of law in Somalia - Somaliland might have something, some parts practice Sharia to some extent, but most of the country is ruled by arbitrary enforcement of will of whatever warlord happens to control that part of the country at any point.
oh BTW, actually I found out about Somaliland just recently, in January I think, but thanks for reminding me anyway.
If you draw your border around North America you find anarchy (the law varies as you move from Mexico to the US). Even within the US, laws vary widely. But if you draw the border around Somaliland, you don't get anarchy (Somaliland has more or less consistent laws).
I'm also not sure why you don't consider a warlord to be the government. In what way does a warlord differ from a government?
yes, if you draw the borders arbitrarily. But it wasn't me who drew Somalia on the World Map.
In what way does a warlord differ from a government?
in what way feudal lord differs from a government? well, for one he's more likely to be enforcing his will, than any widely recognized laws.
Depending on which world map you select, you'll find a single border which encompasses the UK, US, and India. Would you then declare that the British Empire now lives in anarchy?
If you go by official Chinese maps, China is also in a state of anarchy - the laws of China don't apply in Taiwan.
in what way feudal lord differs from a government? well, for one he's more likely to be enforcing his will, than any widely recognized laws.
This criticism applies to most dictatorships. Do dictatorships not qualify as governments?
AFAIR British Empire long ceased to exist. But when it existed it had quite unified law. That's why you have English law in the USA and that's what Law of India is largely based on too.
World map that shows PRC and Republic of China (and Hong Kong for that matter) as a single entity is simply wrong.
But of course, if world maps can be wrong, why are you appealing to their authority two posts up?
indeed, Somalia the political entity ceased to exist. That's why Somalia the geographical entity is in anarchy. Which nobody besides you is disputing. But fine, let's finish this pointless thread, we're not getting anywhere :)
'Government' does not imply any particular form, nor does it imply consent or participation of the governed; the warlord model has had a pretty good run throughout history.
And yeah, none of us drew the border, but neither did the folks who live there...so there figuring it out now. Better late than never, right?
I didn't claim it implies consent, but there is a pretty clear distinction between warlord or feudal lord and "the government", at least to me.
Genghis Khan was pretty powerful warlord, controlling much of Eurasia at one point, but he didn't have the government and he wasn't governing.
There's something else that you need to have in order to be considered The Government than just the ability to kill many and collect tax from many. But I'm too tired to elaborate any further right now. This thread is getting too long anyway.
And yeah, none of us drew the border, but neither did the folks who live there...so there figuring it out now. Better late than never, right?
actually it was largely us, the so-called "Western Civilization" that drew Somalia borders as they are recognized today. My point was that we already agree where that border is supposed to be (and nobody seriously recognizes Somaliland).
That said, you can have whatever opinion you want, but when your opinion goes against hundreds of years of political thought and literature, people will be slightly confused.
isn't this exactly what I said, or are you not able to distinguish between "lack of state" and "absence of state-wide law"?
Well, first of all I didn't place statelessness as the primary condition. By "state-wide" I meant "country-wide" or "land-wide", not "government-wide".
And secondly, I don't know of any other examples, but in my own country's history we had an anarchist society which had clearly defined hierarchy (that doesn't mean that people couldn't move between different levels of that hierarchy): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Territory_(Ukraine)
true, it wasn't probably a true anarchist society, but it is as close as it gets, again as I said, don't know any better.
I apologize for misrepresenting your position, then. I still don't fully understand, but this is getting way offtopic anyway.
> it is as close as it gets,
I'm not ultra-familliar with that particular example, but there is a big list here (It's one of them): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_anarchist_communitie...
Every form of government has downsides, has abuses / abusers. Making a statement like you did implies you think they're fundamentally wrong and should be replaced by... what?
You can't just invoke the importance of the state here--you have to say why the situation is different for banking, but you only address this particular point with childish name-calling and complaints about injured feelings.
Attorney-client privilege and psychiatric privilege exist for different reasons. Attorney privilege comes from the necessary functioning of the judicial system, as you pointed out. Psychiatric privilege, in the opinion of the U.S. Supreme Court, "serves the public interest, since the mental health of the Nation's citizenry, no less than its physical health, is a public good of transcendent importance"
What is the reason that a banking privilege should exist? What "public good" is being served by protecting private transactions that outweighs the harm done by evasion of tax laws or other regulations? That's a difficult question to answer, and simply saying "it's the same as other privileges" is not sufficient.
The banking analogy would be a banker who can't reveal how much money you used to have. Current balance would not be privileged.
[1] Austria uses a system like this - capital gains are flat-taxed at 25% unless you choose to declare them together with other income, falling under income tax (you'd be pretty stupid to do this considering the lowest income tax rate here is 36.5%, but that's another matter). This frequently causes the OECD and the US (the only country to tax its non-resident citizens, as far as I know) exert pressure on Austria (and Switzerland) to try to get them to drop banking confidentiality; they've had some success lately, privacy has been somewhat eroded.
The problem is the other countries don't trust the swiss. They are basically being handed a bag of money and being told trust us. Underreporting taxes benefits the 2 parties with all the information (the swiss and their account holders) and the 3rd is left totally in the dark.
Here in Denmark tax authorities have used that anonymous amount transferred to estimate amount of money in Swiss banks which is supposedly enormous.
They've also gone further, like confiscate data about years of foreign credit card payments by Danish shops and search out anyone using a card from a foreign tax haven country based on e.g. shipping addresses for online shopping, or address supplied for hotels and airplane tickets. Except a few high-profile cases like a famous golf player, this had curiously limited criminal consequences, seems like 98% of those caught where just told to pay the tax and interest on the suspicious amounts.
The next step in the tax fraud battle is analysis of all bank payments from Danish bank to any bank in tax haven countries.
The credit card analysis was done in Sweden previously, so it wouldn't surprise me other countries started using that method as well.
Actually, there isn't. You can have accounts denominated in USD, JPY, EUR or any other sufficiently mainstream currency. It's even free if the amount is big enough, which is actually not that high (low five figures).
Don't worry about the banks though, they make it all back and more in their ludicrous transaction fees.
The US is not a kleptocracy, but Olenicoff (the American who Birkenfeld smuggled diamonds for) has ample experience with them. A bio reads: Having escaped Stalin’s forced repatriation campaign [from Iran], the Olenicoffs sewed what little money they had into their coat linings and sailed for America. In that situation, a banker who helped them might be called a hero.
(Actually, he probably keeps it in a number of countries, like Switzerland, Luxembourg, and the Cayman Islands, just in case some of it gets siezed. But the point still stands.)
Right now peoples only choice is to emigrate to another country.
The other ugly face of tax system is that many, otherwise productive hours and resources, wasted for such a non-productive activity as accounting.
Even that choice doesn't work well.
The US government considers you an indentured servant. Even if you stop consuming the services they are providing with tax dollars, you are obligated to keep paying for them 10 years.
http://travel.state.gov/law/citizenship/citizenship_778.html
If you live in Europe, (presumably) have EU citizenship, and have renounced your US citizenship, what jurisdiction does the US have over you?
We need to collect data b/c the gov't has to know about your income, your investments, etc, etc. But how about a (hypothetical) system where you only pay taxes when you purchase goods. There wouldn't seem to be any fundamental reason to keep information on _who_ purchased what. Just the fact that the transaction occurred.
One problem, though, is that in practice, sales taxes are generally regressive --- the poor spend a much larger fraction of their income than the rich, and so wind up getting (relatively) more heavily taxed.
OTOH, companies routinely exchange services and that kind of transaction is very hard to tax.
That mean the ability to tax fall down like a house of cards and we have to look for alternative ways of running society.
Given the need for taxation, making taxation fair requires information about economic transactions. But there's a balance to be struck here: having the state be informed about the details of every transaction, tied to each individual, would probably be too dangerous for liberty. But on the other hand, lack of oversight will lead to evasion and free-riding. So it seems that it's best to put effort in investigation in proportion to detecting potential free-riders.
Large amounts of money held in opaque arrangements abroad would seem to me to have a high probability of abuse; and with the numbers of people involved being small, the instrumental loss of liberty in having these arrangements investigated seems to me small compared to the free-riding risk.
I also object to the argument you've used; it gives me a slimy feeling reading it. You've tried to drag in this notion of privacy and respect by association with "professionals", attorneys, priests and spouses (!), to what amounts to hired thugs protecting a box of valuables. Banks spend a lot on appearances because they need to give their customers the impression that they're safe places for their customers' money, but at the end of the day, they're out to extract as much of that money as they can. Banking isn't a respectable business, particularly these days. They're a necessary part of the economic infrastructure, a bit like water supply and sewers are to cities.