If these ever existed as two legitimate offers, we're looking at a 5M cap vs a 50M cap.
Who is offering these numbers? Diligence has to be able to 'back into' the cap with traction or revenue. If the 5M cap feels "real", then the 50M cap is hiding something. Extreme red flags should be going up (outsized voting, extreme terms, weird clawbacks, etc). If the 50M cap is more real for the business, then the 5M cap is a joke and generally should be ignored unless there's a very specific reason to take it (but what could that be?).
Either way, a 10x evaluation difference is so off base something does not make sense.
If you think you can do something tangible with the 10 million right now sure, if it results in a lot of PR people, over-expensive office space and a bloated workforce then the money can be a resource curse. Doesn't exactly seem to be a popular attitude these days but I've always been a fan of seeing how far you can go with as little as possible. Keeps the bs out.
You would think that you want to claw as much money from their hands but that comes back on you if you don't think you can grow or maintain the value your company is currently at.
$10M from someone who built their wealth via blood diamonds is very different from $1M from a well-connected VC that can help your business in a tangible way
Whether it’s contacting founders who previously received money from the VC, or plain old web research. It’s really dumb to take money from someone who can make life difficult for you down the road
Coming from someone who worked in a company that received Softbank investment, it's a huge hassle. The ONLY reason to take Softbank money is to get a huge sum of money at a huge valuation and reduce your "cost" of said money. But for me personally, the costs aren't worth it.
First, there's the inflated valuation. It's a great MO for Softbank - they get you by stroking your ego and flashing big (exaggerated) valuations. But does anyone ever think about the next round? No one else after is going to invest at that valuation + extra, unless you really knocked it out of the park, so you are stuck with them for future rounds. Or IPO (Hello Uber). Startups are hard - why are you making it more difficult for yourself to succeed?
Second, the ongoing effort. You don't have one or two guys at a VC firm you are working with, you have a bureaucracy you are working with, in a completely opposite timezone, with a very different working culture.
Maybe it makes sense for a company who is on their last round of funding before IPO, just needs one last cash push to get everything there, and can pay a bunch of people to deal with the BS. But that's not most startups.