Re:Oracle copied Amazon’s API – was that copyright infringem...
by voxic11 on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @08:08AM
(#21979565)
But the license is for an SDK that talks to the API not the API itself which is what they reimplemented. It's like if Google claimed that since Oracle once released an Apache licenced Java application that means they can reimplement any Java APIs that application used.
Re:Oracle copied Amazon’s API – was that copyright infringem...
by fauigerzigerk on Tuesday January 07, 2020 @11:16AM
(#21981340)
My point is that Oracle doesn't have to be right in their potential dispute with Amazon. All they have to do is use a defense that does not rely on denying copyrightability of APIs or on fair use. And that's what they are doing by referring to the SDK license.
Also, the potential damages in these two cases are presumably very different. Google built an entire industry on top of Android whilst Oracle is limping along with a me-too cloud offering, some tiny part of which uses Amazon's API. So I think Oracle would gladly take the risk of losing that case if they can win the other one.