Re:Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisi...
by xamuel on Monday January 06, 2020 @09:48AM
(#21969479)
>undermines the credibility of citing papers
That credibility is already undermined by the fact that for citation-measuring purposes, there's no real difference between any of the following citations:
(1) "Introduction. This paper is a journey into the amazing consequences made possible by (Smith et al, 2019)"
(2) "Introduction. In this paper we show that (Smith et al, 2019) is a steaming pile of crap"
(3) "Footnote. This minor remark is vaguely reminiscent of (Smith et al, 2019)"
All contribute the same citation juice to Smith et al, 2019.
A lack of reproducibility of cited papers IMO undermines the credibility of citing papers.