News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by Erik816 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:36PM (#21964667)
Almost every resource is limited. That doesn't mean they are public goods.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by papito on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:02PM (#21964837)
You can lease land and airwave frequencies. You cannot lease coal, for example. You have to buy and use it, and then it's gone forever.

Additionally, we don't know how much coal there is to still be discovered - we know very well how much land there is.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by chii on Sunday January 05, 2020 @11:50PM (#21966525)
If you over-farm a piece of land, it loses fertility, until it becomes un-arable.

If LVT is implemented, then there would be incentive to over-extract from the land anything that is valuable and can be avoided from taxation (such as fertility, or minerals, or anything else that rises from the land).

I dont think this can be sustainable - because without clear, exclusive ownership that lasts indefinitely, why would anyone value the land at all?

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by dodobirdlord on Monday January 06, 2020 @12:33AM (#21966750)
> I dont think this can be sustainable - because without clear, exclusive ownership that lasts indefinitely, why would anyone value the land at all?

For the same reason that people already rent property they don't own. There are all sorts of value-generating activities that require exclusive right to some land.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by eru on Monday January 06, 2020 @05:56AM (#21968174)
Why? We already have property taxes. They just also tax the stuff on top of the land. Do you see property taxes leading to over-extraction?
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by harimau777 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:55PM (#21964790)
Alternately: Since natural resources are not created by people, there's no reason why a given person should have the right to profit from it to the exclusion of others. They didn't do anything to create the resource, it was there already.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by wahern on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:20PM (#21964957)
> there's no reason why a given person should have the right to profit from it to the exclusion of others.

The social value of private ownership isn't in permitting owners to profit, it's in aligning incentives so that a resource is put to the most productive use. Very often those willing to pay the most money are the ones with the most productive use, and so long as there's a private owner his interests are usually to sell to the highest bidder. More importantly, a private owner can't be corrupted into selling to lower bidders, whereas bureaucratic owners (public or private) can be.[1]

I [very briefly] researched Georgist taxation systems in the U.S. when taking a seminar on land use regulation. My tentative conclusion was that they weren't very effective because the bureaucratic systems for appraisal were very quickly corrupted--not to benefit individual politicians, but to satisfy the electorate, who often find such taxation schemes unfair.

[1] A private owner with multiple interests might be willing to sell one interest to a lower bidder in exchange for a higher bid for some other interest, though.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by harimau777 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @07:02PM (#21965238)
How do you determine what the most productive use is and whether a natural resource is being put to it? If one person owns so much useful land that they don't even have to work and another person works hard but does not own any useful land then I don't think that's a productive use of the land.

I agree with you that Georgism isn't perfect. However, I haven't seen a better solution.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by wahern on Sunday January 05, 2020 @07:41PM (#21965461)
> How do you determine what the most productive use is and whether a natural resource is being put to it?

You can't. No one person can. That's why centralized economic planning doesn't work. (I'm not trying to suggest that Georgism is centralized planning, or that Georgism doesn't appreciate the value and necessity of price signaling.) And private ownership doesn't necessarily lead to the most efficient allocation. But the point is that private ownership is a stable regime. There are an infinite number of regimes that would offer better allocation, but we haven't yet seemed to find one that is stable, or that we can make stable. (A big part of the problem, I suspect, is cultural, so I don't mean to suggest that Georgist systems are inherently unworkable, just evidently unworkable in recent American history. I think our social and political cultures play a big part in what make land value taxation seem unfair.)

That said, if the public believes land isn't being put to good use it can purchase the land at market price.[1] That still leaves accidental and speculation profits in private hands, but theoretically it puts a ceiling on inefficient allocation. Unfortunately, in some ways (particularly politically) eminent domain powers are at their nader in the U.S. Which is a big part of the reason why we can't accomplish things like California Highspeed Rail. I think that drives home the point that Georgist taxation is less workable today than it ever has been in recent history.

[1] That's required by law in some countries, like the U.S. In some other countries it's not technically required by law but it's often the case that the government does pay market price, simply because to do otherwise would seem unfair and lead to political backlash.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by crdoconnor on Sunday January 05, 2020 @09:03PM (#21965816)
>Unfortunately, in some ways (particularly politically) eminent domain powers are at their nader in the U.S. Which is a big part of the reason why we can't accomplish things like California Highspeed Rail. I think that drives home the point that Georgist taxation is less workable today than it ever has been in recent history.

HSR would be easier with a land value tax - there would be a negative incentive to hoard land, so land acquisition costs would be minimised.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by wahern on Sunday January 05, 2020 @10:23PM (#21966159)
Yes, I know.[1] My point is that the current political environment is especially averse to systems which trade private gain for public good. Central Valley farmers have been successful in running out the clock and extracting huge payouts for their land because they can leverage public sentiment to forestall land acquisitions that are both perfectly legal and rather run-of-the-mill. In most holdout cases California courts would order a sale rather quickly, but the state doesn't avail themselves of that option nearly as much as they could. This is how Georgist systems seem to become corrupted--an appraisal results in some sympathetic character (an elderly person or even a businessman) effectively being forced to move or sell, exceptions made, formulas tweaked, inexorably regressing the Georgist system to the status quo ante.

California is a great example: HSR battles and Prop 13 revenue dilemmas are things that land value taxes are directly intended to resolve in favor of the public wealth. But both of these phenomena have strong public support propping them up, directly and indirectly. Prop 13 was passed precisely because the public was concerned about the threat of people being priced out of their homes, and that sentiment is at least as strong today as it was back then. Land value taxes would systematize homeowners' worst fears, and they won't be placated by arguments or even evidence that shows that they're better off on average.

I'm tempted to say that people are just irrational or that the public often wants contradictory things, but that would be lazy--true but lazy. In any event, my point is that resolving these things requires more than simply engineering a system that works better on paper. Incentives have to be aligned not just in dollars, but also in votes; not just at the outset, but also on an ongoing basis. Georgist land value taxation schemes are fundamentally predicated on consistent, long-term application. Once exceptions are made it crumbles because not only do perceptions of unfairness increase, the utility of the regime declines. This is true of alot of things, even traditional land taxation, but it's especially true of land value taxes.

[1] Or at least I'll concede that point. It's not obvious to me if and how prospective public works projects would figure into land values under a Georgist system, especially in the rural areas where HSR battles seem to be the worst. (AFAIK, the more urban areas in and around Fresno were acquired and bulldozed rather quickly.) Particularly with land value taxation, the devil is in the details.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by harimau777 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @08:35PM (#21965706)
That's fair. I suppose partially I'm coming from the perspective of: why should I care if a system is stable if it benefits the rich at my expense. As I see it the idea of liberal democracy is to create a system that works for everyone so that everyone is incentivized to make it stable. As long as that's not the case, then it seems reasonable to be willing to trade some stability for more equality.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by kortilla on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:26PM (#21964994)
Well all resources are made from natural resources, so you’re suggesting that people can’t own anything.
Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by harimau777 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:56PM (#21965194)
No, what I'm suggesting is that the making of a resource is where someone adds value.

So profit that comes solely from owning a natural resource isn't earned; however, profit that comes from the labor of extracting the resource or from making something with the resource is.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by nybble41 on Monday January 06, 2020 @04:10PM (#21973350)
"Making something with the resource" must include having the foresight to preserve it from others who would have consumed it for a less valuable use. The "unimproved value" is what it would have been worth if left unclaimed—not the market value of the land in the actual situation where it was claimed and preserved. The difference between those two prices is earned value even if it doesn't take the form of formal "improvements" built on the land.

However, under that definition there essentially is no such thing as "unimproved value"—unclaimed and unpreserved land would quickly become unusable for any purpose—and the proper LVT assessment in the vast majority of cases would be zero, or else so low as to not be worth collecting.

Re:How Much Land Does a Man Need? (1886) by blazespin on Sunday January 05, 2020 @06:45PM (#21965125)
actually, in some places resources are public goods and are auctioned off regardless of land ownership. eg: https://www.bcplacer.com/basic_rules.htm

yeah, basically you can go prospecting on anyone's private land (some caveats)