News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by echelon on Sunday January 05, 2020 @03:24AM (#21960297)
Regulatory capture.

Do you think we'll see Mickey Mouse enter the public domain? (And even if it does, Disney still owns the Trademark.)

I want to create a company and pump out so much (good) content that we can show the value of copyright is nil. Older content is a very long tail, but the vast majority of revenue is with new art. It's perennially refreshed and relevant to new audiences.

Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday January 05, 2020 @07:10AM (#21960933)
How will your company producing good copyright content be financed?

Copyright seems almost essential to having media creators get paid. I'd go for much shorter terms 7+7 years (7 years automatic right, 7 years paid), and make various other changes (deposit non-DRM copies or you don't get copyright at all, things that can't enter the public domain can't be copyright protected; also the copyright term is set at the start, and can't be retroactively extended).

You might be able to create a "fair recompense" right or something (those exploring works have to pay a fair amount to the original author) but it would still be a form of copyright I think?

Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by shmerl on Sunday January 05, 2020 @03:47PM (#21963965)
> Copyright seems almost essential to having media creators get paid.

Not when it's 120 years long. How exactly are creators benefiting from it? Those who benefit from such long term are various publishers who just sit and profit on what was created long in the past by the actual creators. At that point it's already completely parasitic.

Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by pbhjpbhj on Sunday January 05, 2020 @05:11PM (#21964517)
Yes, but if the term is 0 then the main beneficiaries will also be the publishers, only then the creators will get nothing. At least with a copyright of some form they have chance to make a recompense rather than losing _all_ the financial value of their creations to the Capitalists.
Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by echelon on Sunday January 05, 2020 @07:18PM (#21965325)
It's a hard problem.

I think one negative trend is the focus on creating tentpole films that eat up the competition at the box office. (As well as the consolidation of all major brands and copyrights under one studio.)

Not only are these films watered down to appeal to a wide audience, but they're safe rehashes of the same recurring themes.

By inflating the cost of films, you decrease the diversity. Fewer actors and directors get a chance. Fewer ideas are used. All the screens show the same thing.

I hope that better tooling will help democratize the market. Maybe films don't need to cost so much.

And maybe you're right about copyright. I don't think I can presume to make rules that fair without harming someone. Maybe it's not that copyright needs to be revisited, but rather that the big elephants in the room need to be made to play nice.

I still think more content creation is one answer. By having a greater diversity and abundance of content, you average out the concentration of interest (and value) across the board. This prevents singular entries from soaking up all the benefits.

I don't like the status quo, though. And it's getting worse.

Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by fnord77 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @04:56AM (#21960553)
> I want to create a company and pump out so much (good) content that we can show the value of copyright is nil.

Lessig argues that it's worse than nil - that copyright stifles innovation

Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by colejohnson66 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @09:40AM (#21961398)
I’d argue that copyright does have its uses, but it’s been extended too many times that it stifles innovation now. I know I’d be scared of demoing my product to a company if they could just copy it with no repercussions.
Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by gpm on Sunday January 05, 2020 @11:06AM (#21961854)
They still can, copyright doesn't protect the idea behind products.
Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by colejohnson66 on Sunday January 05, 2020 @12:36PM (#21962508)
I meant to say intellectual property, not copyright
Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by gpm on Sunday January 05, 2020 @01:45PM (#21963045)
For the most part, no form of intellectual property protects ideas that companies and products are formed on.
Re:Rolling Stones tracks posted briefly on YouTube in attemp... by chrismcb on Sunday January 05, 2020 @03:54AM (#21960377)
But the value of copyright isn't nil. I think there is enough evidence to support it isn't.