News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by sandworm101 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @12:12PM (#21955999)
Except that it is increasingly possible to tell grads from non-grads. If all you are concerned with is coding, there isnt much different. But of you look for writing ability, communication capacity, and cultural knowledge, those with only highschool or a few years of online junk really do stand out, not in a good way.
Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by ksdale on Saturday January 04, 2020 @12:21PM (#21956053)
I think this is a good point, but I'm not entirely sure that these skills distinguishes grads from non-grads. I think grads are much more likely to possess these skills for sure, but I would guess that a large percentage of grads don't possess these skills either (at least in my experience).

I don't intend this as a criticism, but rather just an observation, that someone could see writing ability and communication capacity and cultural knowledge and assume a grad, and thus make these types of observations a self-fulfilling prophecy.

Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by throwawayjava on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:11PM (#21956719)
> I think grads are much more likely to possess these skills for sure, but I would guess that a large percentage of grads don't possess these skills either (at least in my experience).

I agree with this assessment. Even some top-tier CS programs seem to routinely graduate students with poor writing skills and sub-par cultural awareness.

I always recommend to interns that they take some writing-intensive courses, and possibly even pick up a minor in a writing-intensive field like English or Philosophy. And then not just take the course, but also use what they learned to write about things free time they way they (should be) writing code outside of their CS courses.

I think a lot of the strong disagreement in HN re: the value of college basically boils down to the huge amount of variety in the college experience.

Surprisingly, this variety has less to do with the quality of the institution and more to do with the quality/preparedness of the student.

A good litmus test for whether someone is wasting college might be to ask the question: what did you read/build/do this semester outside of your courses that used stuff you learned in your curses during the last year or so?

The less impressive the answer to that question, the more likely it is the student should maybe think about leaving college until they're ready to fully engage.

(Obviously, that litmus test only makes sense for full-time undergraduate students... for working students, it might be something more like "how are you using what you're learning in your day job".)

Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by mcguire on Saturday January 04, 2020 @04:05PM (#21957544)
"Surprisingly, this variety has less to do with the quality of the institution and more to do with the quality/preparedness of the student."

Possibly. But there is an enormous range of institutional quality, from diverse, not necessarily elite or even large, schools to the ones existing almost entirely to absorb GI bill and scholarship funding and maybe provide job training.

Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by sandworm101 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @12:38PM (#21956165)
Much depends on which degrees and knowledge we are talking about. Anyone with a STEM degree knows the metric system. Anyone with a law degree can string sentences together into something useful. But a political science undergrad...a few years doing coding bootcamps .... these are not assurances of anything.
Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by networkimprov on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:05PM (#21956679)
Great writers and orators are born, not made. In just the same sense as musicians and artists.

Naturally all of the above hone their skills with practice, but the great ones started from a different baseline.

Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by strken on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:21PM (#21956781)
How can we tell the difference between great writers who are born, great writers who end up on the edge of the Bell curve through random decisions during childhood, and great writers who are deliberately raised to greatness?

Taking you literally, I can't see any reason why greatness should be determined solely at birth.

Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by pm90 on Saturday January 04, 2020 @03:31PM (#21957269)
Did those Great writers learn writing in the womb? Which language are they good at writing in and how did they learn that?
Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by throwawayjava on Saturday January 04, 2020 @02:14PM (#21956739)
Yeah, but I don't need great writers.

I need people who I can trust to given presentations to clients, executives, or directors of other divisions of the business.

I need people who can communicate clearly in writing with clients/stakeholders.

I need people who can write good commit logs, comments, and technical documentation for other engineers.

In the extremely limit, I need people who can write a white paper or research paper.

I'm not looking for the next Dickens or Fitzgerald.

Re:College as an incubator of Girardian terror by abakker on Saturday January 04, 2020 @12:26PM (#21956080)
Kind of selection bias, though. A lot of getting into college is dependent on already being an OK writer. I was pretty good when I got in, studied Econ, and was pretty ok when I got out, without much effort. I ended up with a job where I literally wrote analytical papers for 5 years, straight out of school. That job did a lot more for my writing than college did. I figure I wrote more in my first 2 years of my job than all of high school and college combined.