Re:End-to-end double-ratchet encryption with epoch key exchange
by matthewdgreen on Saturday January 04, 2020 @09:23AM
(#21955015)
The main independent claim doesn’t specifically call out quantum algorithms. I’m struggling to see how Signal/Axolotl doesn’t match every element.
Re:End-to-end double-ratchet encryption with epoch key exchange
by hcknwscommenter on Saturday January 04, 2020 @10:45AM
(#21955452)
And I am struggling to see how Signal/Axolotl does match every element of claim 1.
Re:End-to-end double-ratchet encryption with epoch key exchange
by hcknwscommenter on Saturday January 04, 2020 @11:13AM
(#21955660)
X is certainly not post-quantumn cryptography. You need to look at all elements of claim 1. IN particular, "wherein the first refresh key is generated on the first device based at least in part on the first public key and the root state,
wherein the first refresh key is generated on the first device without requiring a private key corresponding to the first epoch key, and" . . . "wherein the first state is generated on the first device without requiring a private key corresponding to the first epoch key, and
wherein, the first state is generated on the second device based at least in part on the first private key, the first epoch key, and the root state;" and . . . "wherein, on each of the first device and the second device, the first message key is generated based at least in part on the first state and the first refresh key;"
You might remember "But X" patents from when they were all for the Internet. You know "It's a bookshop but Internet" or "It's paying for a magazine subscription but Internet". Some of these patents were subsequently invalidated, many made their "Inventors" plenty of money anyway.
Most of today's sensible crypto designs can be mechanically transformed into something safe for a post-quantum world by sprinkling the right post-quantum ingredients in the right places and putting a XOR somewhere.
The "great" thing about patents is that you can be vague about parts that you don't specifically claim, to the point where they aren't even invented yet, and still succeed in the application. You have to guess that the missing pieces will get discovered, doesn't matter who by, before you stop being able to incrementally file modified patents for the same "invention" and then you can collect all the money because your "invention" is essential.
So they won't even need to propose a specific post quantum algorithm anywhere, they can leave that as a black box. When something gets invented, their patent covers it being used in the obvious way.
This sort of nonsense is another reason patents should be scrapped rather than reformed.