Re:The Polygons of Another World
by zozbot234 on Thursday January 02, 2020 @05:05PM
(#21940434)
And only a few years afterwards, the Acorn Archimedes (launched in 1987!) would achieve comparable or better (especially in 3D) graphics and sound via pure CPU power, with little or no custom hardware. Cool stuff, but it was essentially a dead end architecturally. Even if Commodore hadn't screwed up to the extent it did, that whole generation of machines was tied to the 68k series, and would have died with it anyway. (Even Apple could not save the 68k, they jumped ship to POWER instead.)
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Juste to state what is obvious for many but Archimedes CPU is none other than ... arm, the most ubiquitous cpu on the planet nowadays.
I would contest that, The CPU power advantage was considerable, the 68000 took 4 clocks to add two registers, anything fancier took more, compared to the ARM where you could build the kitchen sink and shift it across a bit in a clock. That was why the 3D performance was so much better. but to gain the capabilities that were available in 2D the advantages of playfields, sprites and copper lists you'd need far more CPU power.
I'm not sure "little or no custom hardware" is a great way to describe the Archimedes.
OP meant custom graphic hardware. Dumb framebuffer is also what Apple Macintosh used, combined with full graphic library in firmware. Brilliant less is more/worse is better approach. Mac graphic accelerators simply patched firmware routines for their own accelerated versions - no drivers, no software rewrites, plop a card and everything is faster.
The Archimedes had custom graphics hardware. The VIDC was an Acorn design.
The VIDC provided a configurable framebuffer (with choices for resolution and color depth), plus a single "mouse pointer" sprite. Audio was just PCM channels. The Amiga custom hardware did a whole lot more than that.
Sure, but the quote was “little or no custom hardware” - a bit wide of the mark! The thing didn’t even have an off the shelf cpu.
ARM is not an "off the shelf CPU"? Would you say that the Commodore 64 didn't use an "off the shelf CPU" simply because MOS Technology was owned by Commodore?
Well, yes and no - it is a slightly modified version, the 6510, so in that sense, yes. But in another sense, no, because what did they do, when they found themselves in need of a CPU? They used an existing design. That's pretty much what "off the shelf" means.
The VIC-II would count as custom hardware, I should think, as it sounds as if it was designed specifically for the C64. Same as the Amiga stuff was designed by the Amiga team for use in their computers. And same as the ARM CPU (and the other bits) were designed by Acorn for use in theirs.
Just leaving "The Ultimate Acorn Archimedes talk" here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hf67JYkUCHQ