News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by softwaredoug on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:28PM (#21937457)
I’ve always been skeptical of “screen time addiction”. In most cases I’ve seen someone addicted to screentime, there’s an underlying issue that’s the real cause. Like a messy divorce causing kids to lose themselves in World of Warcraft, or my own example of picking up coding to “hide” in my own world due to a traumatic childhood. Other cases, I’ll see more normal people binge games or screentime, but usually they pull themselves out and do fewer IRL screen activities after that binge. They don’t lose themselves like I did as a kid trying to escape something.
Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by hinkley on Thursday January 02, 2020 @02:19PM (#21938686)
We use 'crutch' mostly as a pejorative these days but by the original meaning, it's a temporary measure to produce a long-term benefit. It's only when you try to use it past its responsible interval that it becomes a harm. You are supposed to observe that the thing no longer serves a meaningful purpose. Which is very different from saying it served no purpose.

If you don't want to end up with a messy divorce of your own you have to get out there, observe healthy relationships and try to form some of your own.

But to be fair, our knee-jerk reaction to 'addiction' is abstinence and that philosophy is debilitating. Anyone whose spent any time dealing with addiction (as opposed to just making an ass of yourself by reacting to it) will have at least encountered the concept that you have to crowd out undesirable activities with desirable ones. You don't just 'stop drinking'. You also get too busy to be blitzed all the time.

You may or may not also have to abstain. There are games my friends want to play that I won't because I always get sucked in far deeper and longer than they do. Most alcoholics never touch a drop again. That said, I know a 20 year sober alcoholic who figured out he was self-medicating for anxiety, sought treatment, made big lifestyle changes, and can now have a beer once in a while without hulking out.

Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by alexis_fr on Thursday January 02, 2020 @03:44PM (#21939584)
« The Boy Crisis » by Warren Farrell is a good study, it tells a few causes concerning boys. Basically they are forgotten in class or in family because we’re all focussed on equality for women, and they know they’re not the priority. Addictions to video games, porn, media consumption are only a result of a broader societal change into a society of equality.

He’s said to be controversial like Peterson, he talks about the same topics, but from a male-feminist point of view, as he was president of the New York chapter of the National Organization for Women (Peterson is on the opposite spectrum as a Christian/conservative, Farrell is rather a leftist/equalitarian. Both controversial but raising good points).

Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by sibeliuss on Friday January 03, 2020 @01:07AM (#21943672)
You seem to naively underestimate how well designed algorithms and interfaces coerce usage.
Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by rhezab on Thursday January 02, 2020 @12:57PM (#21937818)
I have a similar experience. But it's still super helpful for me to first break the content addiction part so that I have the mental space to try and confront the underlying problems...
Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by vorpalhex on Thursday January 02, 2020 @01:53PM (#21938424)
Right but tools vs solutions. The tool is a screen timer, but the solution is to resolve the underlying problem.
Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by rhezab on Monday January 06, 2020 @09:48PM (#21976303)
Yup. Screen timer is a tool to do help break my addiction, which is the first step of the solution (because without doing that first step, I don't think I'd have the mental capacity to deal with the underlying problem).
Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by setr on Thursday January 02, 2020 @01:41PM (#21938282)
I'm mostly skeptical because there's often an element of misunderstanding.. my own parents repeatedly accused me of being addicted to video games, but really I just wanted to finish the match and they have a habit of updating me with whatever plan very shortly ahead of the event, so I couldn't plan for it effectively (and of course, I was also young enough that even if I tried to plan ahead, I'd do so incorrectly). Or I wouldn't sleep on time because I was enjoying the game... Which I would have done with anything -- games, books, movies, etc. It just happened to be games.

And I'm looking now at my younger cousins being accused of addiction as well, yet it's clearly not. They're see switching games repeatedly, but their parents can't differentiate so it looks like they're stuck on one thing indefinitely. But reality is much simpler -- they aren't well socialized, and their friend circles are also not very well socialized, so they spend most of their time on games. Sometimes together, on multiplayer games, or solo, and then talk about it together later.

But it's clear they're not addicted -- they just don't know how to do anything else. eg they can't successfully gather a group to go to the beach, and neither can their friends, and thus they only know of the beach as somewhere to go with as family (which is never that much fun), and thus the whole circle has no real concept of going to the beach as a group of friends, and so no one in that circle even attempts it, so the concept is never learned.

And then the fix, taking away the games, manages to accomplish nothing.. they still don't know what to do. Their friend circle is naturally not going to switch to some sport, or whatever movie, or whatever else, because it's not in their culture. But their culture isn't developed/exposed enough to do anything else. So they're stuck, bored, and just waiting to get back to the one thing they know how to do.

In my case, I'm pretty sure my parents could have fixed the "problem" with something like paintball, if they really wanted to get me out of the house, or DnD if they wanted me to socialize more in-person. But my parents were too far removed from the problem to think of anything other than what they would do (my father was social, and would have done the standard set of social activities, and my mother only knew to study). Paintball/DnD were however culturally close to be inherently interesting to my friend circle.

The alternative is parents trying things at random until the kid accidentally finds a new friend circle or interest (eg send them to Mongolia, whatever kids camp, whatever classes).

Claiming addiction is IME the easy way out of actually understanding the problem at hand (in my cousin's case, not properly socialized)

Re:Dad takes son to Mongolia to get him off his phone by hinkley on Thursday January 02, 2020 @02:25PM (#21938764)
I know of a hearing impaired kid who talks all day to people online because everyone has the same hearing impairment in teleconferencing; we cannot differentiate between two conversations at once. People are forced to take turns or get peer pressured to do so. Few do this in person.

Parents thought he was socially impaired. Turned out he was an organizer and leader among his peer group.