Bolla says that alioth blew it, by not asking SBCL for full optimization --- and he does in fact get different timing with the optimization in place.
From the original post:
N=500
gcc 0.15u 0.00s 0.17r
sbcl 0.08u 0.02s 0.21r
N=3000
gcc 5.60u 0.00s 5.69r
sbcl 5.18u 0.01s 5.41r
N=5500
gcc 18.81u 0.01s 19.12r
sbcl 17.42u 0.02s 17.76r
I mentioned the alioth page mainly so people could see how gcc was being run.>>Bolla says that alioth blew it, by not asking SBCL for full optimization<<
No he doesn't.
The spectral-norm Lisp SBCL #2 program is Lorenzo Bolla's program - look at the program source code
http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u32/program.php?test=spect...
>>he does in fact get different timing with the optimization in place<<
He get's different timing but the only explanation he provides is "So, different numbers on different boxes, which is not at all unexpected."
>>Bolla says that alioth blew it, by not asking SBCL for full optimization<<
Maybe you should ask Lorenzo Bolla if he was trying to create misunderstanding by posting one of his old (December 5th, 2010) blog entries to HN ;-)
The benchmarks game website has been showing Lorenzo Bolla's spectral-norm Lisp SBCL #2 since December 8th 2010.
1) Here are the timings for the C program you linked (x86 Ubuntu one core) -
spectral-norm C GNU gcc #4
N CPU Elapsed
500 0.09 0.10
3,000 3.31 3.32
5,500 11.13 11.14
2) Here are the corresponding timings "if you tell the SBCL compiler..."
spectral-norm Lisp SBCL #2
N CPU Elapsed
500 0.06 0.16
3,000 4.64 4.70
5,500 15.69 15.72
3) Is the program on the page you linked to faster or slower than the SBCL program ?
http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u32/performance.php?test=s...