Re:Sam Altman and Andrew Yang talk UBI
by mc32 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:16PM
(#21931109)
Qatar should be a good case for long-term study: citizens are guaranteed state jobs, land grants and a free education.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Sam Altman and Andrew Yang talk UBI
by vinay427 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @05:50PM
(#21931303)
No thank you. That's easy to do when 88% of the population are foreign workers, virtually none of whom have a path to citizenship, most of whom are rewarded with relatively low wages, and many of whom face exploitation by various means. It's a feudalistic system that doesn't focus on benefiting the people in Qatar, only the Qatari citizens.
http://priyadsouza.com/population-of-qatar-by-nationality-in...
Sure, but if it can't work in that society, how would it ever work in a more just society?
Re:Sam Altman and Andrew Yang talk UBI
by vinay427 on Wednesday January 01, 2020 @06:08PM
(#21931408)
1. Because every country's economy is not identical to Qatar's. Workers in many countries are more productive (in monetary value, for instance) compared to those in many other countries. Loosely, having workers that bring in more money would allow for needing fewer workers.
2. I don't have a strong opinion on UBI right now, but I don't see how Qatar's exploitative system somehow disqualifies UBI in general. Based on what you described, it doesn't even sound like a universal income: it's neither universal nor disposable income.
So it's too early to tell. But if it does work, then that means under some conditions it can work. If it cannot work, then, there is little hope as their system is kind of handicapped to have a better chance than most.