I don't play chess. But I think I understand the enduring appeal of the game.
Watching games (like in the animation of the Immortal Game on the wikipedia
article) I get this weird feeling as if I'm watching a constraint solver, or a
theorem prover walking through the steps of a proof, where the theory it's
trying to prove is a theory of how to get to a check mate and the constraints
are the moves that "our" or "their" player can make in any given board state.
It's got a very maths-y and logic-y feeling to it and you can see that chess
players play until they can prove to themselves that the game ends, then they
resign or announce their win. The article above says that Kieseritzky resigned
three moves before the end of the game, when it became clear that his defeat
was inevitable. I mean, at that point, the two players could actually
_calculate_ the outcome of the game.
I think a game like this is intriguing to anyone who has an analytical mind,
who likes to study and create algorithms, or to just watch things work. The
fact that the elements of the game are very simple is actually a feature: it's
pared down to the bare essentials, an elegant abstraction that leaves no
ambiguity. Only the elements that matter in the game are actually in the game
(so it doesn't really matter what the king looks like, as long as it's
recognisably a king). At the same time, the combinatorics of the game mean
that an analysis, while straighforward, is anything but trivial, at least until
the game gets to that point where the number of possible moves shrinks to a
mere handful.
The games you list, while they're more entertaining as games than chess, also
have too much superfluous detail, too much that relies on being able to play
the game on a computer to keep track of all the things you (think you) don't
need to think about, like the appearance of units and so on. With the
simplicity gone, the elegant abstraction also goes and analyses of the game
become so much less clear.
If I compared chess to a modern game, that would have to be Magic: the
Gathering. While M:tG is, on its face, a goofy game with dragons and angels,
there is a base set of game elements that is simple enough and easy enough to
understand, and analysing a game with precision is possible and in fact,
pleasing. You can again watch mechanisms work, cogs turn, parts slide into
place as a player develops their strategy. It is intellectually gratifying to
play such a game, because it's perfectly balanced between complexity and
simplicity, it's at the sweet spot where detail is interesting, engrossing,
without it becoming overwhelming (though there are times when M:tG boards can
become overwhelming, say if you have a couple dozen permanents on each side)
(though I get that many people are attracted to it because of the fantasy
themes rather than the gaming component).
Unfortunately, M:tG is a proprietary game and the materials needed to play it
are harder to acquire than chess (not least because they keep making more of
them every few months). So I don't guess it will ever catch on as chess has.
I think a game like this is intriguing to anyone who has an analytical mind, who likes to study and create algorithms, or to just watch things work. The fact that the elements of the game are very simple is actually a feature: it's pared down to the bare essentials, an elegant abstraction that leaves no ambiguity. Only the elements that matter in the game are actually in the game (so it doesn't really matter what the king looks like, as long as it's recognisably a king). At the same time, the combinatorics of the game mean that an analysis, while straighforward, is anything but trivial, at least until the game gets to that point where the number of possible moves shrinks to a mere handful.
The games you list, while they're more entertaining as games than chess, also have too much superfluous detail, too much that relies on being able to play the game on a computer to keep track of all the things you (think you) don't need to think about, like the appearance of units and so on. With the simplicity gone, the elegant abstraction also goes and analyses of the game become so much less clear.
If I compared chess to a modern game, that would have to be Magic: the Gathering. While M:tG is, on its face, a goofy game with dragons and angels, there is a base set of game elements that is simple enough and easy enough to understand, and analysing a game with precision is possible and in fact, pleasing. You can again watch mechanisms work, cogs turn, parts slide into place as a player develops their strategy. It is intellectually gratifying to play such a game, because it's perfectly balanced between complexity and simplicity, it's at the sweet spot where detail is interesting, engrossing, without it becoming overwhelming (though there are times when M:tG boards can become overwhelming, say if you have a couple dozen permanents on each side) (though I get that many people are attracted to it because of the fantasy themes rather than the gaming component).
Unfortunately, M:tG is a proprietary game and the materials needed to play it are harder to acquire than chess (not least because they keep making more of them every few months). So I don't guess it will ever catch on as chess has.