It's a sunken cost fallacy at this point, people have build entire careers on the beta-amyloid stuff and they will NEVER accept an alternative because it would make them irrelevant. These same people hold a lot of power in the field.
* Type 1 diabetes: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2019.12.18.881433v1
* Multiple sclerosis: https://stm.sciencemag.org/content/10/462/eaat4301
* Lupus: https://stm.sciencemag.org/content/10/434/eaan2306
* Sjogren's: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S15216...
* Anti-phospholipid: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S19313...
* Parkinson's: https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/mds.27105
* Alzheimer's: https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/5/1/eaau3333?intcmp=...
It's like the old joke that science progresses one funeral at a time.
Can’t find a single doctor that will take the infection theory seriously. a Year later I can’t get a prescription to even try it.
My vit D is very low. Modern med just say take supplement. Mars shall protocol says that’s just feeding the infection. Supposedly bacteria loves vit D.
Love to find a doctor that doesn’t automatically dismiss me for bringing it up.
So these doctors should both update their knowledge and also give you the benefit of doubt.
There is a growing network of doctors that treat multiple sclerosis with high vitamin D doses. Look for the Coimbra Protocol. They also deal with other autoimmune patients. While their protocol is quite experimental, and it poses some safety concerns, it might be helpful to get in touch with more open minded MDs.
Vitamin D influences so many immune pathways. I tend to think most of the effect comes from altering T regulatory / effector ratios. Others argue for regulation of HLA elements. Irrespective of that, low vitamin D is a big risk factor for many autoimmune disorders so I would question that statement.
Thanks for the information. Will research that protocol.
https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2019.12.18.881433v1
The reason is that both pathogens and your own microbiome mimic your tissue components. Especially proteins. They want to avoid being recognized as non-self, either to infect you or to keep their symbiotic relationship.
Hence, in some scenarios it's hard for the immune system to classify a virus or a commensal as foreign and the mimicked tissue in your own body as self at the same time.
The first reference in my previous post explains it well. Viral mimicry is quite old and well established in the literature both as an infection strategy and as a cause of autoimmunity [1-3]. But microbiome (commensal) mimicry is surprisingly unexplored, except for a few recent studies. Some are those I referred to in my previous post.
Note in many ways tumors are also an immune problem. They should have been caught by the immune system. There is growing evidence that this is also related to mimicry and dysbiosis.
[1] https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-642-74594-2_...
[2] https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199912303412707
Happy microbiome, happy human. Unhappy microbiome, unhappy human.
It seems like more research is published every day that links the microbiome to common disorders and diseases.
Do you have any solid resources for someone without an academic background who has an interest in this area?
What you said is very intuitive however not entirely true. Let me explain: Bacteria are happy no matter what as they (as community of different bacteria) can adjust to content of the human gut; i.e. when we feed simple sugars (in contrast to fibre that is a polymer made of many sugars) some microorganisms will be more than happy to go on simple sugar-diet that requires less energy to consume it. However it can disregulate metabolic network of microbiome that has been co evolving with fibre based diet rather than simple sugars. Early humans consumed much more plant based fibre and therefore we hardwired our human metabolism and twicked immune response to co exist with microbiome that consumes fibre. Let me give you an example: when microbiome gets fibre from our diet it returns us side products of fibre metabolism including short chain fatty acids (scfa). They(scfa) stimulate many receptors in our body and keep us healthy. So in summary: microbiome will adjust its metabolism to what is available and will be always happy given there is any food. Microbes can even consume our own mucosa when we starve or when we die. It is more about keeping the community of microbes at homeostasis (in contrast to dysbiosis). Keeping them on diet that we used to feed them for hundreds of thousands years of our co evolution even preceding primates appearance. Our bodies depend on side products of microbial metabolism of what we used to feed them and definitely not of what western like diet feeds them nowodays. We live in the world of disregulated microbial metabolism. It disregulates us, our own metabolism, our brains, our immune responses, almost all tissues. We cause dysbiosis of the global ecosystems on the planet. This is reflected in the dysbiosis of our own gut. We are degenerating our microbial shield and degenerate our and other species.
Quick entry point, take a look at references in the introduction section of: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2019.12.18.881433v1....
Some other entry points:
* Commensals in hunter gatherers: https://advances.sciencemag.org/content/1/3/e1500183.short
* Commensal extinction: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096098221...
* Fiber, metabolites and the microbiome: https://www.nature.com/articles/nature12726
* Leaky gut and immune responses: https://www.pnas.org/content/116/30/15140
If you are not affiliated with an academic institution, use Sci-hub to get access to any paper behind a paywall.
I've long wondered if infections are behind many of the unexplained mid and late life disorders. It's exciting to see that it's finally being recognized as a credible explanation in the literature. As someone with a family member suffering from autoimmune, I'm hopeful that this trend will continue and result in antigen mediation therapies that can help.
Worth mentioning that the family member I am thinking of developed these symptoms within a year after getting a bad stomach/GI infection.
Just to clarify, it's both infections OR dysbiosis (your own commensal bacteria, fungi and virus going out of control).
The infection + molecular mimicry theory of autoimmunity was already quite well established in the 80s, but commensal dysbiosis + molecular mimicry is only starting to emerge now, and it's likely to be even more important. See section 1 (introduction) of this paper for a whole overview:
https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2019.12.18.881433v1....
Eventually I went back to just eating regular food and within a month it was coming back along with not feeling as great.
I have still never been able to nail it down, and my dermatologist is pretty dismissive of it.
This stuff about the gut-skin axis has only been coming out the last 2-3 years, although there are a few lone researchers who have been thinking this for decades.
For myself, I experienced roughly 80% reduction in symptoms after switching to a strict vegetarian diet two years ago, and it's stayed that way.
Some people have had luck using this method to find issues that doctor visits weren't able to surface.
Agreed, I think it is a universal problem in science.
I have an illness that has been curable for decades now, but this cure is treated with hostility by the medical establishment. I look forward to the day when the cabal of my illness collapses. Hopefully then I will be able to talk about what happened without people getting angry.
in fairness, i think people have a hard time taking claims like this seriously without a little more information, due to its superficial similarity to those of a "crackpot". (but while the _precision_ is pretty poor on the correctness of "crackpot" theories, the _recall_ is pretty much 100%)
arguably > 100%, to be a bit tongue-in-cheek
"One common theme in the chronic Lyme communities is that people who go into remission tend to attribute their response to whatever technique, supplement, or medication they were trying at the time."
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21707343
Once people form a community around a particular therapy the community will never admit that the therapy was wrong.
On the other hand https://equilibriabook.com/ gives shocking examples of how the medical establishment was wrong even though all the information was available and an individual could do much better not following mainstream medical advice. That can happen when the incentives in the research institutions are misaligned.
This is a subject I also put a lot of thinking into recently:https://medium.com/@zby/rational-patient-community-6d3617dff...
The manner in which someone presents their ideas is a decent secondary indicator. Common red flags include being evasive about what disease they're referring to, being unable to demonstrate where the mainstream theory fails, being unable to point to any good experimental evidence that even hints that the crackpot theory may be an equal or better explanation, not being able to anticipate and have a good answer for the most obvious questions raised by the crackpot theory.
The illness is chronic mercury toxicity and the treatment is chelation therapy. I know a man who reversed his dementia with chelation therapy. He's an older guy that would get lost in his own neighborhood.
Steven Fowkes, a chemist, has done a lot of work in presenting the some of the latest research regarding Alzheimer's and how it relates to mercury toxicity. A good start is his Quora answer here: https://www.quora.com/Why-havent-we-made-progress-in-a-cure-...
Some other good scientific literature is the work of Boyd Hayley with the chelator emeramide. He's in the process of getting it approved through the FDA for treatment of acute mercury toxicity. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3346673/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/29444690?dopt=Abstract
> It [his cure for Alzheimer's] isn't a proven reality so if you're looking for double-blind clinical studies of this you're gonna be disappointed. But if you're willing to suspend your disbelief and try something as simple as giving your family member without Alzheimer's disease something like coconut oil and B-complex vitamins and see if it works, you may be very pleased.
Suspending disbelief should not be a requirement to make a persuasive argument about a scientific subject. This guy just smacks of snake oil salesman through and through.
Perhaps this paper would be better than the videos. I posted the videos because they are easier to understand. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1046/j.1471-4159...
I think mercury is a major factor in many illnesses, and the root cause of mine. I did have some serious memory issues for a while, and my ability to focus was so bad that I could not watch a TV show. There are tens of thousands discussing the same kinds of symptoms and how they disappear with chelation.
I think the source of mercury exposure, duration of exposure, intensity of exposure, where the toxicity eventually settles in the body, and genetic factors all play a role in the symptoms that an individual suffers from. That is why one toxin can cause such a wide range of illnesses. The "radium girls" who were poisoned working with radium in factories is a good example of this.
And I'm not sure why you describe Boyd Hayley's work as low quality. The man has published a huge amount of work, much of which was funded by the NIH.
Ultimately I think the highest quality evidence is the actual curing of sick people. I know my claims of being cured and of others being cured are hard to believe. If you saw first-hand the transformation we went through then you would know we are on the right track.
I'm not saying his work is necessarily low quality. I'm saying that attaching his name to work makes it less credible from the outset, because his reputation is so thoroughly tarnished be things like his anti-vax positions. Likewise for Fowkes and poor credentials and track record. If you want to convince someone whom you've already given reason to be quite skeptical, you need to be able to provide citations from experts whose Google search results are free from such obvious self-inflicted problems.
Unfortunately, you've been profiling the code and you've found that the there is an inordinate amount of time being spent allocating a date. It seems like the code is pathologically looping around and hitting that date code hundreds of thousands of times for every request. You've tried showing your lead the code that's causing the problem. He doesn't really understand it. He doesn't trust code profiling either. He already knows what the problem is and he's not interested in hearing any more. He ridicules you for having this stupid theory that allocating a date is slowing down the DB.
It's not that keeping the poor behaviour is benefitting him in any way. It's more that the new solution is not his solution and he's got a lot riding on his solution being chosen (justify his code rewrite). He's kind of staked his reputation and career with the company on his solution. If it turns out to be something else -- especially something he's already ridiculed, he'll be toast. He wants to get into management and management is all about politics and being right all the time (ever hear the President say, "Wow. I was certainly wrong about that!" -- and you can pretty much insert just about any President there... not just the obvious one ;-) ).
That's the way I see it anyway. Doctors, just like computer programmers work with complex systems where they are more likely to be wrong than right. I never trust people in these positions who don't know how to be wrong. But they/we are often placed in positions where we are not allowed to be wrong -- and some people handle those situations better than others.
It might also be worth to add that he might have been subjected multiple times to alternative theories that were refuted, and in his eyes this new outlandish theory isn't even the most credible one on that list.
There is often nothing you can do to help anyway, but you can certainly bill 250 bucks every 5 minutes, and many, many do so.
In fact, some physicians will not even accept complicated cases, especially if they involve chronic pain treated with opiates, thanks to the hysteria around overdoses today.
And that is the reason why universal healthcare will fail, and why the NHS has a private tier, and routinely pays for treatments outside of the UK, done in private hospitals.
This does not logically follow from what you said at all. The NHS has not "failed", nor does it have a private tier - it commissions some treatments from private clinics for purely political reasons. These treatments are still completely free to the patient.
An NHS hospital isn't receiving insurance payouts, so it has an incentive to treat people quickly and efficiently, with complete cures being preferred over long-term management when possible.
You will get to see a private consultant a lot quicker, than the very same physician via NHS referral.
Quite literally you could wait months, or pay a few hundred and see the same exact person in a couple of days. In fact, when paying private - the private consultant himself will be treating you, vs. when on NHS - it will likely be his students/trainees that will be hands-on.
NHS hospitals are on a fixed budget, but of course cost controls means nothing - only putting patient interest first /s.
2) As for the insurance payouts - that was regarding systems where physicians bill on fee-per-service model, the most predominant setup in the US: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/20467910
It's unfortunate to say that the very tenants science tries to eliminate are actually normal parts of human behavior. Our actions, logic and reasoning are dominated by emotion and an attempt to hold onto power. Status seeking and religious bias are normal parts of human behavior.
The irony of it all is that we hate this type of behavior but are seduced by it nonetheless. A good analogy is the Dark side of the force.
One thing I've seen people fall for is that they think they're immune to this bias by being aware that it exists. Nothing is further from the truth. We are all victims of bias and we are all not immune because to be biased is to be human.
Clinical trials are happening for mushrooms as well.
Still super glad to see psychs being studied. It always frustrated me that due to scheduling in the US it was much harder to study them.
The success of an approved drug like ketamine in treating depression and chronic migraines has opened the doors for studying other hallucinogens.
Chronic Fatigue Syndrome treated by chelation therapy. His hypothesis is that mercury poisoning caused it.
OP is not an anti-vaxxer but was accused of being one because they blamed mercury.
OP also had bone fractures and fascia disintegration.
OP also had tense forearm muscles (?) described as 'rock hard' due to RSI.
I don't know why you're being so vague about it. It's likely you're being downvoted for the vagueness rather than anything else. Still, he has an email listed if you're curious.
I led with the details on a different account. My karma was destroyed and afaict my posting privileges were revoked for posting too frequently with explanations. I don't think you understand the huge amount of anger that some people have towards people like me saying mercury caused this illness.
Leading vaguely and easing people into the details prevents my karma from being destroyed. I'm not sure how else to handle this except by not talking about it at all, but the only way I can make meaning out of my experience is to help others with the same illness, so I will continue to do so. I found the cure from posts like the one's I make now. I'm paying it forward.
Who would have thought that, on HN of all places, a request for privacy would be interpreted as a license for abuse?
What the fuck do those even have to do with each other?
Also, upvoted for actually posting object-level claims rather than whining about downvotes.
It's not antivaxx, but it's antivaxx-adjacent, and awful stories like this is what people think of when someone promotes chelation against the medical consensus.
https://www.medpagetoday.com/neurology/autism/1616
That doesn't prove anything about any particular use of it, but that's why people can get very angry when it comes up.
Now, it turns out that the very small amounts of thiomersal in vaccines were probably safe. This was by no means obvious at the time. Mercury poisoning is nasty - the symptoms can appear long after the initial exposure, range from death to subtle neurological effects like changes in behaviour and loss of IQ, and appear at relatively low exposures. Also, there just wasn't all that much modern research into thiomersal or its metabolite ethylmercury.
I am interested to hear what you have to say.
sadly there is still a lot of hostility to even this treatment due to hesitation around long-term antibiotics, and recovery takes months - making it difficult to observe. and i think only a few doctors are aware of it as an option.
I'd just like to clairify that I downvoted because of the lack of details, not their presence.
That’s a great quote. Pretty much any activity that humans are involved in are at risk for this type of behavior. Egos get involved and objectivity goes out the window.
I wrote about how scientific research is broken earlier this year, and what you're describing is one of the most pernicious. https://medium.com/@barmstrong/ideas-on-how-to-improve-scien...
https://www.researchhub.com/about is a project I'm helping get off the ground which hopefully can help this problem, by eventually replacing the traditional journals. Still early days (just beta launched).
But the ResearchHub model of open collaborative assessment could have provided more incentives and visibility for research that deviated from the beta amyloid hypothesis.
It sounds like gatekeepers were a large problem here... i.e. peer reviewers for journals or grants that were insistent on beta amyloid. Disentangling dissemination from assessment (as preprints are doing) will help bring contrary findings to the light.
We also need to make all assessment public. Rather than basing the validity of a study on a few anonymous unpublished reviews, let anyone provide feedback and increase the sample size and diversity of assessment. Finally, add some incentives for contrarians who advance unpopular hypotheses that time proves correct.
Anyways, lot's of thoughts, but I agree a radical shift in how scientists communicate could help get to the root of the hivemind described in the article and by @cockatiel_day.
this is depressing, means I have to second-guess if I have found a cause to spend energy on
My first job out of college 10 years ago was in a lab focused on Alzheimer’s research. Our Principle Investigator made an art of writing grant applications for studies that would appear to be in line with mainstream theory, but were really intended to test theories he actually thought were worth testing, presented in results as an “interesting” aside. He believed the amyloid theory had been conclusively disproven.
He explained to me that people like him work for decades, quasi-retire into positions accepting grant applications, and have a conscious or unconscious agenda to preserve or validate their life’s work. His money quote was “science is like the Catholic Church, a lot of nice sentiments but full of people”.
I don’t have any evidence or examples, but I suspect this dynamic is not limited to Alzheimer’s research.
Another anchor to research not mentioned in the article is how much sponsoring universities take from research labs. To put a university endorsement on our research, which is needed to be credible, the university took half (half!) our grant money.