News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by chrisseaton on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:41AM (#21914020)
> what are all these Ph.D.'s going to do?

Get a job like anyone else would? Why must academia or industrial research be the only plausible options?

After doing a PhD you can be a high school teacher, a soldier, an actor, start a company, go into politics, do whatever you want. Nothing’s stopping you!

Most jobs just want capable educated people, and many vary diverse educational backgrounds.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by arethuza on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:50AM (#21914100)
Of course nothing is stopping you doing those things (and most people I knew who did PhDs do end up doing something fairly unrelated outside of academia) but if those things are your goal then why on earth would you want to do a PhD?
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by chrisseaton on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:51AM (#21914115)
> why on earth would you want to do a PhD?

Is there nothing that you do inherently for the challenge or joy of it?

I did my PhD because it was a challenge and I had a lot of fun doing it and found it extremely rewarding.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by ng12 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:04AM (#21914232)
Well sure -- if you can afford to spend six years of your life dedicated to a hobby by all means do so. Most people aren't afforded that luxury and need to worry about the practical applications of a PhD.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by JoyousFailure on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:26AM (#21914421)
I'm failing to understand what your point is.

Like the parent comment said

>After doing a PhD you can be a high school teacher, a soldier, an actor, start a company, go into politics, do whatever you want. Nothing’s stopping you!

Most people don't go into debt for a PhD afaik. Failure to monetize a PhD directly just means falling back into the more traditional workforce.

Stable job in a small city isn't enough of a practical application?

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by ng12 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:34AM (#21914499)
The average PhD stipend is around 30k, even for high COL areas. If you have an undergraduate degree (especially if you've incurred debt to do so) it's not a particularly attractive option. Especially true considering how competitive and stressful most PhD programs are.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by chrisseaton on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:38AM (#21914541)
> it's not a particularly attractive option

It obviously is attractive, since people chose to do it.

Maybe they're thinking about more than money?

Why do you care anyway? Are these people who take a reduced income to better themselves and others through learning a particular thorn in your side for some reason?

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by ng12 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:43AM (#21914597)
> Maybe they're thinking about more than money?

My point is many people don't have the privilege to do so. The article specifically references individuals who sought higher education as a path to a better life -- so if I have a thorn in my side it's the tone-deafness of saying it's not about money.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by chrisseaton on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:51AM (#21914686)
> My point is many people don't have the privilege to do so.

But I don't think this matches up with what I know from reality. People get a stipend for a PhD. Yes it's not massive, but it's enough. I think all student loan systems that I know of have repayments means tested, so you don't have to repay if your income is low.

Maybe you lose some income opportunity, but I don't see how makes it less accessible as long as the stipend is enough to live on?

A PhD seems particularly accessible to me, actually! More accessible than an undergraduate degree since it's all paid for!

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by ng12 on Monday December 30, 2019 @12:03PM (#21914797)
> Maybe you lose some income opportunity

It's just not opportunity cost. As the article references, many PhD degrees don't increase earning potential at all in part thanks to the adjunct system.

So to be clear in the US it's a four year undergraduate degree (which usually comes with debt), then five or six years of working for near-poverty wages to obtain a PhD, and when you finally get it you find that you haven't increased your earnings potential from when you had no degree at all. It's fine to wax philosophical about getting a PhD to become a well-rounded gentleman but the issue at hand is higher education failing those relying on it for professional success.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by chrisseaton on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:20AM (#21914371)
> Most people aren't afforded that luxury and need to worry about the practical applications of a PhD.

Most qualified people at reputable institutions get paid to do a PhD. I bought a house and had a baby while doing a PhD. It needn't hold you back.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by ng12 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:31AM (#21914472)
The average PhD stipend is barely above the poverty line. You're financially better off doing just about anything else with your undergraduate degree.

I'm glad you had the luxury of pursuing a passion PhD without sacrificing your personal life or worrying about future career prospects. Most students I've known did not have that privilege.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by kxyvr on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:48AM (#21914640)
I've been through the Ph.D. process and while I agree that stipends should be larger, it is not insurmountable. Specifically, what you're missing is that stipends are a 9 month salary and that many students, including myself, take summer internships that make up the difference. I was paid $23k in stipend a little over a decade ago. I also worked for a technical employer for three months each summer that paid about $35/hr, which brought in about $17k in additional income. Occasionally, I would work a month in the winter as well to bring in additional income. That said, I was making about $40k a year at the time and I know for certain that salaries both at my university and for said employer have risen.

And, yes, my final year I did not work the summer in order to finish my thesis. Yes, I understand that not everyone has the luxury of additional employment. However, it is not a truism that those of us who pursue a PhD must sacrifice their personal life or career prospects. It improved both of mine.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by arethuza on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:37AM (#21914536)
I think chrisseaton is in the UK - here a lot of people work as researchers on short term contracts and do PhDs at the same time. While not competitive with private sector salaries they didn't use to be too bad - I got married and bought a flat in the 1990s while working as a Research Associate on EU funded projects.

NB Traditional PhD studentships did get a pittance, but relatively few people seemed to do these (at least where I worked).

Edit: Also I had no student debt, which definitely makes things easier.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by ng12 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:40AM (#21914557)
The article above is about the American University system (and non-STEM degrees at that). If it's different in the EU it's not particularly relevant.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by pbhjpbhj on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:42AM (#21914581)
6 years seems long?

3 years I think is standard in the UK, for example (https://www.prospects.ac.uk/postgraduate-study/phd-study/wha...).

Strikes me you should say your locality and field of study as doctorate length seems like it would be a function of both of those.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by gipp on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:48AM (#21914651)
The structure of post-grad programs is fundamentally different between the two. In the UK you generally have a Master's already before beginning a PhD, while in the US you typically enter a doctoral program directly from undergrad and pick up a Master's "on the way".

6 years is probably pretty typical in the US for the sciences. For the humanities it's generally even longer (often due to the need to work to support oneself due to lack of funding). I recall seeing somewhere that the _median_ history PhD takes 11 years.

Edit: seems I misunderstood the UK structure, perhaps I was confusing with continental Europe? Not sure about the time difference in that case.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by chrisseaton on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:59AM (#21914765)
> In the UK you generally have a Master's already before beginning a PhD

No that's the opposite - in the UK you normally either do a masters or a PhD but not both. You can leave your PhD partway through and you get a masters though, maybe that's what you mean.

A canonical PhD in the UK is three years of undergraduate and three years of PhD, so six years from leaving high-school equivalent. Some people take one or two extra years in practice.

I had a colleague in Austria who did a full high-quality PhD with top-tier publications in just two years!

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by arethuza on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:56AM (#21914724)
"In the UK you generally have a Master's already before beginning a PhD"

That's not my experience - you can generally go straight from an undergraduate degree to doing a PhD - I did and most of the people I knew did the same (and the people who had Masters either had done MEng as a first degree or had MSc conversion courses).

NB There is also the weird thing where some UK institutions give you a MA for still existing after a few years....

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by ng12 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:45AM (#21914612)
The article is specifically about the American University system.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by pbhjpbhj on Monday December 30, 2019 @12:01PM (#21914780)
Well, it seemed to address wider societal issues and use USA more as an exemplar of what's failing, to me, though I didn't read it in depth.

Even the article geographically contextualises its examples; which suggests to me they at least realise they address a global audience on the web.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by mattkrause on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:08AM (#21914261)
Same here. Other friends joined the Peace Corps, Teach for America, or even the clergy for the same reasons.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by wbl on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:53AM (#21914135)
Because you love the subject. Not everything in life is about pursuing material goals.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by kstenerud on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:58AM (#21914178)
Because your family is rich enough for you to remain out of the job market all those extra years. I wouldn't be surprised if the PhD becomes a new indicator of wealth and power once everyone realizes how uneconomical it is.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by mattkrause on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:07AM (#21914250)
Very few people from my science PhD program were from rich families. I can’t remember what everyone’s parents did, but it was mostly things like nurses, teacher, civil servant, and Christmas Tree farm owner. Professors’ kids were over-represented, but it wasn’t like a pack of Rockefellers and Kennedys. Also, you’re not really “out” of the job market; you’re doing the most viable first step for landing an R&D job.

I knew fewer folks in the humanities, but you might be right there: some were certainly doing this on a lark.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by throwawaymath on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:16AM (#21914331)
How did you form this opinion? Family wealth has almost nothing to do with an individual's financial ability to do a PhD. You don't pay tuition and you receive nominal wages to support yourself. It's not a tech salary, and there's a major opportunity cost for delaying your entry to industry (if you eventually go that route), but that doesn't mean you need a rich benefactor to sponsor you for five or six years.

A PhD is financially viable for anyone who could make ends meet while working at Best Buy. Most people working on a PhD have no family or mortgage.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by gipp on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:29AM (#21914449)
This is only accurate for funded PhDs, which in the humanities (the implicit focus of the Chronicle) are a small minority.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by throwawaymath on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:31AM (#21914471)
Okay that's a fair point, my experience has only been with funded PhDs.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by lhjiourewi on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:03AM (#21914218)
PhD is the new "I have a university degree". Now that basically everyone gets a university degree, you need a new way to signal that you are a very educated person.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by learc83 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:14AM (#21914311)
2% of people in the US have doctorates. In the 60s around 13% of men had a 4 year degrees (it was lower for women, but fewer women were working).
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by lhjiourewi on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:18AM (#21914351)
Lets look at the 40s, instead of the 60s.

1940 - 4.6% had a bachelor university degree

today - 33% percent have a bachelor, but only 2% have a doctorate

> For the first time in history, 90 percent of Americans over 25 years of age have finished high school. In addition, more than one-third of Americans over the age of 25 have a college degree or higher.

> That is a big change from 1940. At that time, a Census Bureau study found that less than 25 percent of the U.S. population had completed at least four years of high school. It also found that just 4.6 percent had earned a four-year bachelor’s degree or taken additional classes after completing a study program at a college or university.

https://learningenglish.voanews.com/a/us-census-bureau-ameri...

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by learc83 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:32AM (#21914482)
So phds are the new bachelor's degree in comparison to the old bachelors degrees of nearly 100 years ago when more than 2x the rate of people had bachelors who now have phds, not in comparison to the old bachelors degrees of 50 years ago when 8x the rate of people had bachelors who now have phds?

Look people aren't going into phds with the goal of signaling they are educated to the general job market the way people used to go for bachelor's degrees. They go into phd programs because on the whole they are very interested in a specific subject and desire to work in research or academia.

Your argument might hold for master's but not phds.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by lhjiourewi on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:39AM (#21914549)
> not in comparison to the old bachelors degrees of 50 years ago

"Degree inflation" didn't happen last year, it was a slow process.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Educational_attainment_in_the_...

> people aren't going into phds with the goal of signaling

I've seen plenty of programming jobs with "PhD required". For example pretty much any "data-science" job at any company.

> Some jobs that used to require a master's degree, such as junior scientific researcher positions and sessional lecturer jobs, now require a Ph.D. Also, some jobs that formerly required only a Ph.D, such as university professor positions, are increasingly requiring one or more postdoctoral fellowship appointments. Often increased requirements are simply a way to reduce the number of applicants to a position.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credentialism_and_educational_...

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by learc83 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:46AM (#21914634)
>"Degree inflation" didn't happen last year, it was a slow process.

So you think we're going to get to a point in 10 years where 10% of the population has a phd?

>I've seen plenty of programming jobs with "PhD required".

So have I. For research jobs. Please show me the general programming jobs that have phds required.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by blaser-waffle on Monday December 30, 2019 @02:30PM (#21915972)
Where do Master's fit in with this?

I know lots -- LOTS -- of people in various industries with a whole smattering of Master's degrees. A lot of them are MBAs, but plenty aren't.

Conventional wisdom says that PhD's are for academia & research. I'd posit that an MA or MS is the new "university degree".

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by rb808 on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:48AM (#21914085)
> After doing a PhD you can be a high school teacher, a soldier, an actor, start a company, go into politics, do whatever you want.

Most PhDs dont want to do that stuff which is why they got a PhD in the first place.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by blairbeckwith on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:50AM (#21914099)
That's tough. Not everyone who wants to be an actor gets to be an actor either.

People have to settle for not fulfilling their dreams every day.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by rossdavidh on Monday December 30, 2019 @06:32PM (#21917652)
True that, but a system that relies on a steady stream of people with unrealistic ideas about what they're doing and going to do, is not a healthy system. Either it will continue to receive misplaced hopes and turn them into cheap labor, or it will not. Either way is bad.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by papito on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:03AM (#21914221)
Not to take this off track, but imagine how much more prone to taking risks we would be if we had guaranteed health insurance. No one wants to risk financial ruin and death in poverty.

The "winners" usually come from old money and then just play with VC billions, never risking a dime, or at least not much.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by blairbeckwith on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:07AM (#21914252)
I'm very fortunate to live in Canada, and can't imagine how much harder it would be to take risks in the states. When I left my stable job to pursue my own small business, my health wasn't even one of the factors I considered. I have never asked for details about health insurance prior tom accepting a job.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by andreilys on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:20AM (#21914368)
Yet for whatever reason Canadians are far less likely to take risks than Americans.

https://www.theglobeandmail.com/report-on-business/economy/c...

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by SaxonRobber on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:34AM (#21914505)
That’s the culture. The risk takers just need to go south for more opportunities anyway, why stay in Canada?
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by blaser-waffle on Monday December 30, 2019 @02:44PM (#21916054)
I don't know why this is getting downvoted. I'm an American living in Canada and I totally agree. Canada has a better minimum wage, so the middle-of-the-bellcurve crowd has it a lot better. Like, I could afford to go back to bartending and live a decent lifestyle, albeit probably have a roommate (I'm married though, so that's covered).

However, STEM salaries are on the order of 40% lower -- lower overall numbers on top of 20-30% currency difference (CAD to USD, with CAD being weaker to drive exports). If you're a motivated engineer you're headed south, getting into oil & gas (where salaries are still decent), or learning to accept things as-is.

OTOH the number of well adjusted people, broke people, and all-around happy people is higher north of the border.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by papito on Monday December 30, 2019 @10:54AM (#21914142)
Right. Some people are afraid of discovering that they cannot compete in "real life". Those fears are mostly unfounded. In many cases this stems from over-demanding parents, making children question their worth. "Can I really be as successful as my parents if I enter the workforce? Or will I find out that I am not capable?".

And so they hide out in academia to see when they are ready to take that risk. After a certain point, they just stay there.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by kevinventullo on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:25AM (#21914409)
You cannot possibly be suggesting that academia is a path one takes to avoid competition.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by papito on Monday December 30, 2019 @12:21PM (#21914967)
If one is already in academia and is fairly successful, why not? I am not saying that's why ALL people stay in academia. Some really love it for what it is, but I have seen it first-hand.

One sibling working her ass off to prove that she can be as successful as her parents, under tremendous stress, and the other one never leaving school to not even deal with that.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by pbhjpbhj on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:46AM (#21914631)
Not OP: Seems a reasonable hypothesis with the proviso of "avoiding commercial competition". Competing academically is different to competing commercially/financially and it seems reasonable that those who've mastered working in academia might struggle to adapt to corporate or other non-academic roles?
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by lolinder on Monday December 30, 2019 @12:20PM (#21914952)
That's not always true. After my dad didn't get tenure, he went to try to work elsewhere but kept getting told he was overqualified. He eventually found a job that didn't care, but the PhD actually did act as a barrier to employment for a while.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by rossdavidh on Monday December 30, 2019 @06:28PM (#21917631)
You certainly can, and that's what most do, but...that's not what they're getting a Ph.D. for. If you ask the people getting a Ph.D. why they're doing it, far more imagine themselves becoming a researcher and/or professor, than will be able to.

It's kind of like student spending huge numbers of hours playing basketball or football in college, when they have no prospect of making it as a pro. If that's what they want to do, fine, I'm sure the lessons about hard work and teamwork and practice and executing to a plan are all useful.

But, if far more of them think they are going to go pro, than actually will, then it's not ok. The current Ph.D. system is not ok.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by mattkrause on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:01AM (#21914207)
All true, but the money for training science grad students comes from taxes (via the NIH or NSF), and it’s not insubstantial: figure 20-30k/year for a stipend, 25% fringe on top of that, and another 30-40k for tuition, which comes out to hundreds of thousands of dollars per grad student.

If we wanted high school teachers or soldiers, there’s got to be a better way. And realistically, it’s hard to pivot into some of these fields while relatively poor and in your 30s. Can’t join the marines after 28, for example...

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by learc83 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:06AM (#21914243)
>30-40k for tuition, which comes out to hundreds of thousands of dollars per grad student

Are there schools where tax money is actually paying tuition though, as opposed to the school just waiving tuition?

> Can’t join the marines after 28, for example

That's enlisted. If you have a phd you'd almost definitely join as an officer, which you can do until 30. And you have until 39 if you want to go into the Air Force.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by mattkrause on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:09AM (#21914264)
Almost all of them!

In biomedical fields, the NIH provides institutional training grants that often cover all students' first 1-2 years. There are usually slot for more advanced students too. In parallel, there are also individual training grants (like the NSF's GRP and the NIH's NRSA) that also cover tuition. Alternately, an advisor's research grant (again, often tax-funded) can cover a stipend--and sometimes tuition too.

Waivers do exist, but they're often used for international students or in exchange for "service" (i.e., teaching) and fairly few people get through grad school entirely on waivers.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by learc83 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:19AM (#21914360)
What percentage are funded through NIH training grants? Also I could definitely be wrong, but from a quick Google search it looks like NIH training grants limit tuition to $16k per year.
Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by mattkrause on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:31AM (#21914469)
If you're looking at this: https://grants.nih.gov/grants/guide/notice-files/NOT-OD-19-0... you need to add up all of the numbers.

They're covering a stipend at $24,816, tuition at up to 16k, "training-related expenses" at $4200 and an institutional allowance of another $4200. There are undoubtedly other sources of money too (center grants, etc).

I'm emphatically not saying this is a bad thing in general. However, I do think it might be worth considering diverting /some/ of this money to fund jobs for the people we're training.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by learc83 on Monday December 30, 2019 @11:39AM (#21914550)
>They're covering a stipend at $24,816, tuition at up to 16k, "training-related expenses" at $4200 and an institutional allowance of another $4200. There are undoubtedly other sources of money too (center grants, etc).

I get the stipend and expenses. It's the 30-40k in tuition that I'm questioning. At my school CS grad students just got a tuition waiver, and as far as I know it wasn't directly paid for by grants.

As for the stipend. They are doing research, so you have to evaluate the money in that context. If they are doing useful work for that $25k it's not a waste even if they don't end up working in research after finishing.

Re:The University Is a Ticking Time Bomb by mattkrause on Monday December 30, 2019 @12:12PM (#21914888)
I don't have my offer letter (and in any case it is a decade old), but the tuition part was definitely higher than $16k. It is possible that the sticker price isn't very useful, and they're taking whatever they can from outside sources and waiving the rest.

There are other costs too: here's an interesting study that tries to estimate non-tuition, non-stipend costs https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4353078/#B6 These, since they're mostly faculty time, are also partially paid for by funders.

In any case, my point is that grad student labor is both important surprisingly expensive and it's not at all clear to me that we have the "right" amount of it. Specifically, I think it might be better, from a research productivity and a "system health" persepective, to have somewhat fewer grad student slots and a few more staff scientist positions: Maybe 70/10 instead of 100/~0.