But right and wrong aside, there's the practical matter of reality. You can't simply pretend everything works how you want them to. At the end of the day you have to deal with how they actually work.
The Linux project needs to be able to evolve independently of other projects, so they do just that.
This is a classic case of technical architectures following most of the time social structures.
> Systems calls form an API and it needs to be stable and managed.
In some cases (e.g; nearly all the other oses...) system calls form an internal API, and they don't need to be stable, and they actually even don't need to be accessible except to intermediate layers provided in a coordinated way.
My preference is that the Windows/OS X model is where the boundary should belong.