News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Monopoly is Stifling Free Software? by marcus_holmes on Sunday December 29, 2019 @11:50AM (#21906870)
OK, I get this.

But look at it from the other point of view: how does a non-technical user determine if a binary download is malicious?

And how, then, does Google/Microsoft/Apple protect those users from their ignorance?

Given that the internet is full of people attempting to get non-technical users to download malicious software, often my mimicking exactly the sort of site the OP has created, then is it really practical to insist that Google/Microsoft/Apple allow the OP's site to download software to a user's machine freely?

The advantage of the middle-man is that it acts as a trust agent (not necessarily well, of course). If you download a malicious binary from an App Store, that is the App Store's fault for letting it on there in the first place.

Re:Google’s Monopoly is Stifling Free Software? by thristian on Sunday December 29, 2019 @06:42PM (#21909457)
Sure, you need some kind of middle-man as a trust agent, but Google/Microsoft/Apple are not the only possible trust-agents, and their model is inherently biased towards certain useful software production models.

Let's say I keep bees as a hobby, and I write some small piece of software that tracks and calculates something to do with honey production. I post it to my favourite bee-keeping forum, other people try it and like it, and when a new bee-keeper joins the forum they're often advised by forum regulars to try my software out too.

That kind of software can be a huge help to people, but it's not a good fit for an appstore because it's never going to turn a profit, and at least on Apple's store (with the $99/year publishing fee) it'll drain money quite predictably and regularly.

A bee-keeping forum will never be trusted by as many people as Google/Microsoft/Apple, but the people who do trust it probably trust it a lot more.