News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Monopoly is Stifling Free Software? by zozbot234 on Sunday December 29, 2019 @08:18AM (#21905729)
> Because the default distribution mechanism for free-as-in-speech software is Github, these days.

I surmise that this mostly impacts non-free platforms, where compiling software from source used to be quite non-trivial so it was common to just download binaries. These days you can probably get LLVM to work everywhere, though.

Re:Google’s Monopoly is Stifling Free Software? by simion314 on Sunday December 29, 2019 @09:45AM (#21906096)
Each user compiling a binary is a lot of waste, have you compiled a large project like Chrome or Unreal Engine ? If you are even able to compile it successfully it takes hours on a recent i5.

A few years back at my work we were digitally sign our binaries, so I don't think non free platforms are affected at all since it is not expensive to buy a certificate , only hobby/personal projects will be affected.

Also a signed binary does not mean there are no viruses or other bad things inside, so I am wondering if we want to identify the source of the binary can we find a technical solution so you can have your website and binary with the same key then you know that binary X is from X.com people, for some reason a few years back this certificates for signing were not cheap.

Re:Google’s Monopoly is Stifling Free Software? by zozbot234 on Sunday December 29, 2019 @10:47AM (#21906451)
> Each user compiling a binary is a lot of waste

It's not "waste" if it's needed to establish trust.

> A few years back at my work we were digitally sign our binaries,

Just publishing hashes for the (reproducible) unsigned binaries over a secure channel (such as HTTPS as verified by Let's Encrypt) will give you the exact same security. Digital signatures embedded in executables add no security whatsoever, and make reproducibility harder. Just don't do it.

Re:Google’s Monopoly is Stifling Free Software? by simion314 on Sunday December 29, 2019 @12:13PM (#21907025)
I think it is technically possible to sign a binary and have reproducebility for the people who care, you might need a different binary/package then the current ones but it is technically possible.

We had to sign our applications to prevent scary warnings to appear and then we would have to train our users to ignore that.

Re:Google’s Monopoly is Stifling Free Software? by celticmusic on Sunday December 29, 2019 @06:13PM (#21909310)
The worst part is that a malicious signed binary could just download the malicious parts afterwards. Signing isn't really an answer for google.