I can believe that various stray neural impulses may still end up getting sent, or that I subvocalize key words and my conscious self doesn't notice. But in the sense that I think people expect, where we could just take the subvocalizations and somehow lift them up to vocalizations with some obvious transform and understand the results? No way.
There's a world of difference between "everyone whether they realize it or not are fully reading aloud every word they read, just too quietly to hear" and "various small stray impulses may make their way down to the vocal cords". Perhaps there is lack of clarity about what "subvocalization" means?
I also find it hard to believe on the grounds that while by no means can I sustain this for long periods of time, I can be speaking to someone while reading something else. Generally I have my sentence "queued up", so to speak, so it isn't consuming the executive function, while I'm using the executive function to read. Even thought this may be for small single-digit number of seconds, that's still plenty to find it hard to believe that I am simultaneously "subvocalizing" what I'm reading while I'm also vocalizing a completely different set of words, which may not even be on the same train of thought.
Maybe an experiment could involve a fictional ideogram language, and compare peoples subvocalizing (or lack thereof) versus their native one.
Japanese was my first foreign language. I could read a lot of Chinese while having no idea how to pronounce it. Furthermore, once I learned some fairly basic grammar in Chinese, I could read some texts with a fairly high level of accuracy.
All that said, I’m pretty sure I sub-vocalized in Japanese.
I will also say that there are words in both languages where I have forgotten the pronunciation of certain characters, but I remember what the characters mean.
Thinking more about this some more, I’m pretty sure that there is a conceptual and/or visual “sub vocalization” that I have experienced where I clearly knew what something meant, but the words to say it in any language didn’t readily come to my mind. Specifically, there are concepts in Japanese (esp classical four characters combos) that I almost certainly didn’t know the pronunciation of, but I knew exactly what they meant, and the idea didn’t really directly translate into English (e.g., 不惜身命, which was use by Takahanada/Takanofuji when he became yokozuna).
Isn't this a common occurrence when you just can't think of a word, but it's on the tip of your tongue? Another thing that's similar to this would be all the symbols we run into in real life. Things such as traffic signs, trademarks, settings buttons, hamburger menu etc.
Tip-of-the-tongue definitely is a part of symbolic knowledge/cognition.
That said, what I am speaking of is much more complex. The example I gave for Japanese, while most educated native speakers would have known the pronunciation, the meaning was not obvious. As a non-native speaker, the translation was something like "with the devotion of a Buddhist monk", but that doesn't really convey the intensity of the phrase. Even today, when I try to translate it into English, my explanation does not do the phrase justice. When I try to explain it to not-so- linguistically-gifted Japanese people, I can provide a gist fairly easily (just as in English), but the weight of the phrase is tough to convey.
In English, I might equate this to when someone uses just the right Latin or Greek term. The literal translation is fine, but the depth of the meaning is almost impossible to describe while being almost palpable to those in the know.
This is actually how many people learn Japanese. They get an anki deck with kanji and their meanings and learn from that. The decks might have some pronunciations of the kanji, but typically not all of the pronunciations (or people don't learn them). This leads to a situation where they can read text and understand most (all?) of it, but would have difficulty reading it out loud.
Japanese kanji (and Chinese hanzi) are logographic. Each symbol denotes a word or a phrase and depending on the context it can have a different pronunciation, however the meanings generally stay rather similar.
One thing I noticed about myself is that I often subvocalize large numbers (say, 64521) in my native language, especially when I'm reading a language I'm not fluent in.
On the other hand, perhaps this is not the best example, because somebody learning the language would already be slow enough at reading that sub-vocalization wouldn't make a difference.
In fact, a fairly popular way to self-teach Japanese involves utilizing a book series called "Remembering the Kanji", which teaches the meanings of kanji without any readings at all in the first volume. People are able to comprehend quite a bit on a basic level after volume 1 - no grammar and no way to speak or understand spoken word, but generally enough to get a rough idea of texts published at a fairly basic level.
However, I imagine most people at this point, for most words, are probably subvocalizing the english word or meaning in their heads. It's pretty common, even for people that know the proper pronunciation, to still keep translating in their mind vs. just using the word in the foreign language. Personally, I really only subvocalize the Japanese pronunciation for words where they aren't really directly translatable. Kawaii is a good example - it's easy to just translate as 'cute' and it's a word a lot of non-Japanese speakers know, but it doesn't really convey the full meaning of the term and all of the cultural aspects of it. Shikataganai/shogunai are another common example. Phrases and words that don't have accurate direct translations are generally the first people learn to think of totally in their secondary languages, and a lot of people never progress beyond that.
Which is a long way of saying it's hard to tell on this because someone who knows another language could be subvocalizing in their primary language, and someone who only knows the non-alphabetic language but can't pronounce it is pretty unlikely to exist, since most kids learn to speak and hear before they learn to write and read.
The exception would be people that are born totally deaf - and then you don't need to use a non-alphabetic language. They wouldn't know the sounds to be able to subvocalize them even in an alphabetic language.
Doing some quick googling, it looks like even some people that are born deaf develop a subvocalization alternative, with pictures, sign language, etc., though some do not develop the habit at all: https://books.google.com/books?id=8PhwXf9uj1IC&pg=PA114&lpg=...
I did make up my own pronunciation, if that's what you mean.
(sorry for the spam. couldn't resist)
yes, sorry.Once it becomes muscle memory, there's no longer a script (which is why the password is no longer consciously available) for you to execute: you trigger the first finger motion, then it all happens more or less automatically, since the individual finger motions are linked together by sensory cues. Software becomes firmware as it were. I suspect those who claim not to subvocalize could be in an analogous situation, which would mean that they aren't really adopting a fundamentally different approach to reading. Their 'reading program' still takes the same shape as normal people, only a component of it is outsourced and so is no longer consciously available.
Incidentally Charles Dickens wrote about Laura Bridgman (the first deaf-blind person to learn to 'speak' English by communicating with her fingers) and said you can literally visually tell when she's thinking since she'd be moving her fingers. That sounds like the analog of subvocalization for her.
> Her social feelings, and her affections, are very strong; and when she is sitting at work, or by the side of one of her little friends, she will break off from her task every few moments, to hug and kiss them with an earnestness and warmth that is touching to behold. When left alone, she occupies and apparently amuses herself, and seems quite content; and so strong seems to be the natural tendency of thought to put on the garb of language, that she often soliloquizes in the finger language, slow and tedious as it is. But it is only when alone, that she is quiet; for if she becomes sensible of the presence of any one near her, she is restless until she can sit close beside them, hold their hand, and converse with them by sign.[20]
I bought a book on speed reading because I was dissatisfied with my "slow" reading, only to discover that according to their tests I was way up there in both speed and comprehension :-D
I was shocked to learn from that book that many people subvocalise - it felt so foreign (and utterly cumbersome) to me. I hadn't even considered people did that.
Most of the book was about not subvocalising - which I don't think I do anyway, so I never read it to the end.
Indeed if I read to my kids I'm often simultaneously reading one sentence aloud, and reading 1...2 sentences ahead for myself so I get the voices right. So in effect I'm reading the entire text twice while speaking it once.
Even if your vocal chords were doing the full range of motion (they are not), when speaking, you also have to open and close your mouth, move your tongue, take in breath and expel it etc. It's much more than simply some activity in your vocal chords.
It's also very hard to focus on what I'm reading because I'm constantly thinking on a meta level about how I'm reading. I find this is less intense if I'm reading something online and not in book form. Anyway my point was just that I think you are 100% correct in that there are people who do not subvocalize, but if you try to test it they will probably subvocalize.
I never subvocalize, and can't remember ever having done so, except perhaps when I was very young. I devour fiction books in flow without it.
Trying to do it feels really weird to me.
Can you spot incorrect use of "a" vs. "an" in text? You're subvocalizing.
Are you unable to read while talking? You're subvocalizing.
The idea of not-subvocalizing is to see text as images. You should be able to recognize chunks of words like you recognize different types of emojis or types of dogs. It is completely different from the way everyone learned to read.
I can not-subvocalize after much practice but only temporarily.
I don't recommend it. It's useless on the same level as learning Dvorak.
Your tests for subvocalizing are not all correct (spotting "a" vs. "an" does not require subvocalizing).
I do experience text as visual stimulus without sound, and I do process it in clumps. As I mentioned elsewhere in the thread, I once experienced reading multiple lines simultaneously, perceiving not just sentences but paragraphs all at once.
It was quite a rush.
It's not something I can control, or something I can do on command, but I think it is decent evidence that I don't subvocalize.
> It’s simply not possible to comprehend what you’re reading and avoid using that inner voice. So reading faster means being able to use this inner voice faster, not eliminating it. To further that, expert speed readers who were studied also subvocalized, they just did it faster.
I’ve seen this argued elsewhere, and am not convinced they’ve found readers who do not subvocalize to study. Most readers subvocalize. Even if you don’t, if you ask about it, then you do (like asking someone to not think about their breathing).
If you do not normally subvocalize, you become painfully aware of it when you drop into it, feels like slamming on the brakes, and very difficult to let go of again.
I suspect the studies referenced[1] have simply not studied those who don’t subvocalize, akin to studies missing the phenomenon of aphantasia until 2015. Or, they’ve established experimental conditions where the reader cannot help but think about it, causing it to occur.
1. https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4229